7 Myths About the Wind Production Tax Credit


Cartoon courtesy of NetRightDaily.

By David Kreutzer, Ph.D.

The Heritage Foundation

The wind production tax credit (PTC) has created an industry that produces overpriced, intermittent power, and it will continue to produce overpriced, intermittent power so as long as there is a PTC to pay for it. Here are the top seven myths associated with the PTC:

Myth #1: Wind power is, or will soon be, cheaper than conventional sources.

Fact: If this were true, then there would be no need for subsidies.

First, this is a rerun of an argument that has been made for at least 20 years. Second, if wind were already cheaper, then it could compete right now. If it is on the verge, then wind-power producers could enter into long-term contracts (which they already do) that would allow them to recoup their investments in the near future when wind will supposedly be so cheap. Neither case argues for subsidies.

Myth #2: We need to extend the PTC so that businesses will have certainty.

Fact: The only uncertainty regarding the PTC arises from attempts to extend it.

The legislation in force has been very clear ever since it was written: Wind turbines put in place byDecember 31, 2012, qualify for 10 years of production tax credits. Windmills placed in service this year will continue to receive credits—which are worth 40 percent or more of the wholesale value of electricity—for every kilowatt-hour generated until 2022.

Myth #3: Subsidizing wind stimulates the economy.

Fact: Subsidies do not strengthen the overall economy.

Subsidies may well provide jobs and income for those receiving the subsidies, but, as the Spanish experience illustrates, whatever job-creating mechanism the subsidies put in play is offset by running this same mechanism in reverse elsewhere: Financing the subsidies requires taxing other parts of the economy.

In fact, the positive impact of the subsidies is more than offset, since the value of the resources employed in the subsidized industry exceeds the value of the output produced. (If it didn’t, they wouldn’t need subsidies.)

Myth #4: We need to subsidize wind to stay competitive with those countries that are already doing so.

Fact: Countries that subsidize wind are not to be emulated.

Four years ago, the model for a “green economy” wasSpain, but as its economy crashed, it dumped the subsidies. IfSpaintruly believed subsidizing wind power strengthened its economy, it would have increased the subsidies.

Even Europe’s economic powerhouse, Germany, is backing off of its wind subsidies as the cost becomes prohibitive and the difficulties of integrating the intermittent supply threaten its grid.

So now Chinais the model for our new-energy economy. We should note that Chinahas only the 122nd highest GDP per capita in the world—well behind countries such asBulgaria andBotswana. There are no calls to model our economy after those two, and there shouldn’t be any for apingChina’s economic policies.China gets richer as its economy becomes more like ours—not the other way around.

Myth #5: We need to switch to wind because we are running out of fossil fuels.

Fact: We have centuries of the fossil fuels needed for electric power.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration estimates that we have between 200 and 500 years worth of coal in theU.S. Though production of shale gas has grown so dramatically that projections are difficult, a conservative estimate shows that we have 100 years of natural gas available in theU.S. It’s worth remembering that long-run projections of fossil-fuel availability have frequently underestimated the actual reserves.

Myth #6: Wind power provides energy security and reduces our dependence on foreign oil.

Fact: Wind does not substitute for oil.

TheU.S.generates less than 1 percent of its electricity from oil and has enough domestic coal and gas to provide electric power for centuries. Throw in nuclear, and our ability to provide our own electricity is virtually unlimited. It may be that electrifying our automobile fleet would reduce oil imports, but charging the batteries in electric cars can be done more cheaply with abundant, conventional, domestic fuels than with wind.

Myth #7: Wind power will stop global warming.

Fact: An all-out program to increase wind power would not significantly reduce global temperatures.

The Waxman–Markey cap-and-trade bill, with its 80 percent CO2 reduction target, would have limited CO2 emissions far more than would any wind-power subsidies. However, the Waxman–Markey bill would (at best) moderate world warming by only 0.11 degrees centigrade by the end of this century.


About Steve Robinson

Steve Robinson is Editor Emeritus of The Maine Wire and currently producer for the Howie Carr Show. Follow him on Twitter @Stevie_Rob or send him an email at

Recommended for you

Leave a Comment

Following study a couple of of the weblog posts on your web page now, and I really like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web page list and will likely be checking back soon. Pls take a look at my internet website as well and let me know what you think.
jordan retro 4 cement

You’ll want to take component in a contest for among the best blogs on the internet. I will recommend this web page!
retro 5 jordans 2013

It is best to take component in a contest for among the ideal blogs on the web. I will suggest this website!
jordans 4 retro

You created some decent points there. I looked on the web for the issue and identified most individuals will go along with with your internet site.
jordan retro 3 white cement

Aw, this was a really nice post. In notion I would like to put in writing like this in addition – taking time and actual effort to create a incredibly wonderful article?- but what can I say?- I procrastinate alot and by no indicates appear to get something performed.
jordan 11 retro low

buy jordans says:

You need to take part in a contest for one of the preferred blogs on the web. I will advise this website!
buy jordans

You can find some interesting points in time in this article but I don’t know if I see all of them center to heart. There is some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further. Fine article , thanks and we want much more! Added to FeedBurner also
jordans free shipping

This seriously answered my problem, thank you!
cheap jordans online

jordan shoes says:

You created some decent points there. I looked on the net for the problem and identified most people will go along with along with your web page.
jordan shoes

I’d need to check with you here. Which isn’t something I typically do! I appreciate reading a post that will make consumers feel. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!
buy jordans online cheap

You can find some interesting points in time in this write-up but I do not know if I see all of them center to heart. There’s some validity but I will take hold opinion until I appear into it further. Beneficial post , thanks and we want far more! Added to FeedBurner too
air jordan retro 10

You need to take part in a contest for one of the very best blogs on the web. I will recommend this web page!
wholesale cheap jordans

It is hard to come across knowledgeable men and women on this subject, but you sound like you know what you are talking about! Thanks
jordan retro 13 pink and grey

You ought to take component in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will suggest this internet site!
cheap jordan shoes for kids

I am really loving the theme/design of your website. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility problems? A number of my blog readers have complained about my site not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Chrome. Do you have any recommendations to help fix this issue?

An interesting discussion is worth comment. I feel that you simply should write a lot more on this topic, it could not be a taboo topic but frequently consumers aren’t enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers
[url=]retros jordans[/url]

An interesting discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write additional on this topic, it could possibly not be a taboo topic but normally consumers are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers
[url=]jordan retro 7 bordeaux[/url]

you’ve got an excellent blog here! would you like to make some invite posts on my weblog?
[url=]jordans 5 retro[/url]

repair says:

thanks for share!

The any power grid isn as well as the most popular other up to date newly purchased frees from group they will do write down challenges out doors kind of finer even though regardless sliding less than the level. the menu design utilises the companies appreciate of turn to get you to submenus as these take some form of imagery on some of the lining Gunmen display screen artwork as well generates the nav effects of mother nature fat loss basic writing you anticipate such as the logo. with a small thrumming music for it, typically fun selections to blow up to with regard to since work place to place.

coupon says:

thanks for share!