The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Maine Joins Lawsuit Against Trump Administration Over Defunding Planned Parenthood in the Big Beautiful Bill
  • Angus King Signs on to Bill That Would Make it Easier for Some Illegal Immigrant Children to Obtain Green-Cards
  • Higher Maine Milk Prices Now Under Fire As Consumers Decry Lacto-Socialism
  • Collins Presents New Naval Contract to Construct a New Destroyer at Bath Iron Works
  • A Legal Fight Between Hemp Companies Suggests Synthetic Chinese Cannabis Intoxicants Are Flooding American Smoke Shops
  • She’s SO Good: Kamala Harris Whines About ‘System’ Being ‘Broken’ After Spending Years Shaping It
  • John Hudak Weed Agency Licensed Ex-Con to Grow Cannabis in Violation of State Law: Somerset Sheriff
  • Bear Gawkers at Acadia, Baxter Parks Beware: the Guy in the Car Behind You May Be Just as Excitable as the Bear
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Friday, August 1
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
The Maine Wire
Home » News » News » Maine Joins Lawsuit Against Trump Administration Over Defunding Planned Parenthood in the Big Beautiful Bill
News

Maine Joins Lawsuit Against Trump Administration Over Defunding Planned Parenthood in the Big Beautiful Bill

Libby PalanzaBy Libby PalanzaAugust 1, 2025Updated:August 1, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey has joined a coalition of twenty-one Democrat-led states in suing the Trump Administration over a clause in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act that defunds Maine’s branch of Planned Parenthood Family Planning, and other similar organizations.

The provision in question blocks Medicaid reimbursements for services performed at facilities deemed ineligible due to their association with Planned Parenthood, one of the nation’s most prominent abortion providers.

On Monday, a federal judge ruled to blocked enforcement of this measure while the lawsuit makes its way through the courts.

The fifty-eight page injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani of Boston — an appointee of former President Barack Obama (D) — argued that the effort to defund Planned Parenthood amounts to a violation of the Constitution.

According to Judge Talwani’s interpretation, preventing clinics associated with Planned Parenthood from receiving Medicaid funding represents a violation of their First Amendment rights and denies them equal protection under the law.

Talwani draws attention to the fact that the any clinic associated with Planned Parenthood would be blocked from receiving Medicaid reimbursements regardless of whether or not the individual clinic provided abortions.

Although the federal government contends that this clause of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act does not seek to regulate speech, the judge asserts that the “record demonstrates that Members’ affiliation via their membership in Planned Parenthood Federation is expressive.”

While Congress has the power to “‘define the limits’ of a spending program,” as it is not obligated to “‘subsidize activities that it does not wish to promote,'” it cannot reach beyond the “‘contours'” and set conditions “‘that seek to leverage funding to regulate speech outside the contours of the program itself.'”

The plaintiffs in this case have also alleged that defunding Planned Parenthood and its affiliates is tantamount to a “Bill of Attainder,” or a law punishing a specific group without a trial.

The government has pushed back on this interpretation, pointing out that non-Planned Parenthood entities are also impacted by the provision and highlighting that it is based on future conduct.

Talwani sided with the plaintiffs on this, noting that Planned Parenthood was an “easily ascertainable” target of the law when it was passed and again mentioning that the block would apply to any affiliates of Planned Parenthood regardless of whether or not they themselves perform abortions at their facility.

With respect to the non-Planned Parenthood entities mentioned in legislation, Talwani labels them as “no more than collateral damage.” The judge believes that the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on this claim because the “outer bounds of the affected class [were] based on retrospective criteria.”

Regarding the plaintiffs’ claims about alleged equal protection violations, the debate in this case rests on whether or not the measure advances the goal of reducing the number and government subsidization of abortions.

Talwani argues that the bill was not “precisely tailored” toward preventing taxpayer funds from going toward abortions because the defendants do not dispute that “virtually all abortion providers who participate in Medicaid––other than Planned Parenthood Members––unaffected.”

“Plaintiffs are likely to establish that Congress singled them out with punitive intent,” Talwani wrote.

Click Here to Read the Full 58-Page Ruling

In joining this lawsuit, Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey suggested that the effort to defund Planned Parenthood is a “direct attack on the healthcare access of millions of low-income Americans, disproportionally affecting women, LGBTQ+ individuals, and communities of color.”

“With rural hospitals under constant threat, there are many rural and low-income Mainers without access to health care providers. Without Planned Parenthood and Maine Family Planning, these patients in Maine will simply have nowhere to turn for routine healthcare,” said Attorney General Frey.  

Click Here to Read Attorney General Frey’s Full Statement

White House spokesperson Harrison Fields said in a statement to Reuters that the ruling was “not only absurd but illogical and incorrect.”

“It is orders like these that underscore the audacity of the lower courts as well as the chaos within the judicial branch,” said Fields. “We look forward to ultimate victory on the issue.”

Art
Previous ArticleAngus King Signs on to Bill That Would Make it Easier for Some Illegal Immigrant Children to Obtain Green-Cards
Libby Palanza

Libby Palanza is a reporter for the Maine Wire and a lifelong Mainer. She graduated from Harvard University with a degree in Government and History. She can be reached at palanza@themainewire.com.

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

Angus King Signs on to Bill That Would Make it Easier for Some Illegal Immigrant Children to Obtain Green-Cards

August 1, 2025

Higher Maine Milk Prices Now Under Fire As Consumers Decry Lacto-Socialism

August 1, 2025

Collins Presents New Naval Contract to Construct a New Destroyer at Bath Iron Works

August 1, 2025
Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

Maine Joins Lawsuit Against Trump Administration Over Defunding Planned Parenthood in the Big Beautiful Bill

August 1, 2025

Angus King Signs on to Bill That Would Make it Easier for Some Illegal Immigrant Children to Obtain Green-Cards

August 1, 2025

Higher Maine Milk Prices Now Under Fire As Consumers Decry Lacto-Socialism

August 1, 2025

Collins Presents New Naval Contract to Construct a New Destroyer at Bath Iron Works

August 1, 2025

A Legal Fight Between Hemp Companies Suggests Synthetic Chinese Cannabis Intoxicants Are Flooding American Smoke Shops

August 1, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.