The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Nukes and Cukes: In Negotiating with Iran, the Patient and the Determined Always Have the Edge
  • Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants
  • Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent
  • Three More Mills Vetoes – Tribal Eminent Domain, LGBTQIA+ Recovery Housing, Ferry Power Grab
  • China Tries Getting Rich In America’s Backyard
  • Rockland Police Search for Man in Connection to Reported Assault
  • Residential and Condo Associations in Maine Can No Longer Ban Members from Installing EV Chargers
  • Angus King Co-Sponsors Republican-Led Bill Mandating Steps to Combat Chinese Espionage
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Tuesday, June 24
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Commentary » Trahan: Journalists should focus on the bad guys
Commentary

Trahan: Journalists should focus on the bad guys

Steve RobinsonBy Steve RobinsonMarch 6, 2013No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

Some within the media have wrapped themselves in the flag of the freedom of access law. They are rallying to oppose legislation proposed by the Sportsman’s Alliance of Maine (SAM) and sponsored by Rep. Corey Wilson, Augusta that would make concealed weapons permit holders names and information private. Critics of this legislation are ignoring recent history in New York.

Just after the Connecticut school shooting, the Gannett- owned, Journal News published the names, addresses and a detailed map of concealed permit holders in two New York Counties. The action was obviously a provocative attempt to label law abiding concealed permit holders with a scarlet letter.

In a Fox News story titled: “Burglars Hit Home of Gun Owner ID’d by Newspaper”, New York State Senator Greg Ball was quoted: “The Journal News has placed the lives of these folks at risk by creating a virtual shopping list for criminals and nut jobs,” said Ball. “If the connection is proven, this is further proof that these maps are not only an invasion of privacy but that they present a clear and present danger to law-abiding, private citizens.”

The response from the New York legislature and Americans was swift and overwhelming. Under intense pressure, New York passed legislation protecting this information. Twenty three states ban the release of any information about permit holders another 12 states limit the release in some form. The Journal News then pulled the map from their web site. What was absent from this debate was an outcry from journalists and editorial writers regarding the misuse of the Freedom of Access Law.

In the case of the Journal News, reporters didn’t use the information gathered to hold government officials accountable. Instead, in the wake of the Connecticut shooting, they used the information to expose law abiding gun owning citizens for some political motivation-the very opposite of the intent of the Access law.

The Maine Freedom of Information Coalition makes this statement on their web site, which reinforces my point:

“The Maine Freedom of Information Coalition believes that government best serves the public when it operates in the most open manner possible. We seek broad access to information of and about government and the actions of government in order to do that. Government in the sunshine, we believe, is the best guarantor of a strong democracy.”

The entire state freedom of access statute speaks of citizen’s rights to access the work of government, not the right of individuals or groups to use the public’s information for political purposes!

In the wake of this controversial scandal, SAM introduced legislation to make concealed permit information confidential here in Maine. Just one day after running a story about this bill, the Bangor Daily News (BDN) revealed they had requested the same information, but did not plan to make it public. Again, the firestorm was swift and just a day later under pressure from Maine people, the BDN rescinded their request.

We thought the crisis was over. However, just hours later, I learned that two anonymous entities had made identical requests of Maine police departments. In a surprise to many, it appears that state law does not compel individuals requesting FOAA information to reveal their identity. Could we surmise these latest FOAA requests for concealed permit holders are also press outlets attempting to avoid the same backlash as the Bangor Daily News?

Does anyone else recognize the incredible hypocrisy of journalists using a loophole in the FOAA law to hide their identity and then claiming they support transparency and accountability for everyone else?

There are several indisputable facts in this debate:

  • Law abiding Mainers have, by law, subjected themselves to a federal background check, a mental health screening, character examination and a host other investigations to receive a lawfully mandated conceal permit.
  • According to recent newspaper accounts and law enforcement statements, concealed carry permit holders have never been linked to violent crime in Maine.
  • Concealed carry permit holders are being used as political pawns in the gun control debate.
  • Some unethical members of the media have created this crisis. Worse, the rest have failed to police their ranks.

SAM introduced this bill because we were concerned for the safety of Maine citizens and their property. Maine law enforcement has confirmed on many occasions they also share that public safety concern. We just wish the press would spend as much energy outing the bad guys as persecuting the good guys.

By David Trahan

Executive Director, Sportsman’s Alliance of Maine

 

Follow us on Twitter @TheMaineWire

“LIKE” us on Facebook

 

Concealed Carry Permits firearms FOAA Freedom of Access Act Guns Opinion Sportsman's Alliance of Maine
Previous ArticleSen. Alfond: "We might have to stop paying the hospitals"
Next Article New Poll Shows Government-run Schools Not Meeting Demand
Steve Robinson
  • Twitter

Steve Robinson is the Editor-in-Chief of The Maine Wire. ‪He can be reached by email at Robinson@TheMaineWire.com.

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

Nukes and Cukes: In Negotiating with Iran, the Patient and the Determined Always Have the Edge

June 24, 2025

Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants

June 24, 2025

Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent

June 24, 2025

<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="5520 http://www.themainewire.com/?p=5520">No Comments

  1. Dirigo Blue on March 6, 2013 8:17 AM

    I’m sure that Mr. Trahan has returned the database of names of Mainers holding hunting and fishing licenses that SAM obtained under the previous executive director. Will Mr. Trahan tell us if SAM used the database for political outreach during his tenure, and what other databases of public records his group has?

  2. Nancy Hudak on March 6, 2013 8:17 AM

    And Mr. Poliquin has done the same with the email lists he has from being State Treasurer.

  3. Dirigo Blue on March 6, 2013 9:02 AM

    And as Gawker reports:

    When Tennessee first tried to make gun records private in 2009, the effort died “amid fears that political groups and gun advocates would no longer be able to access addresses of handgun carry permit holders to add to their mailing list soliciting contributions,” according to the Associated Press.

    Indeed, in a survey of public records requests filed in 7 of the states that make (or formerly made) gun records public (we’re still waiting on answers from 9 more), Gawker found multiple examples of the NRA and other conservative, “pro-gun” partisans seeking the lists for their own political and fundraising gain.

    http://gawker.com/5987293/the-nra-wants-to-keep-gun-records-secret-from-everyone-except-the-nra

  4. Sportsman's Alliance of Maine on March 6, 2013 1:32 PM

    Dirigo Blue
    Where do you get your information? Make it up! George Smith (three executive directors ago) requested the e-mail of sportsman, not the list of names and addresses. The political parties are the ones who mine this list of IF&W addresses and names for targeted sportsmen mailers. The e-mail list is long outdated, never used and worthless.The legislature made the e-mail confidential. The same thing should happen with the concealed carry info. I am not George Smith, had nothing to do with this decision, I do not plan to- and will never exploit peoples private information for SAM gain. Please explain what Democrats are doing with the concealed carry info stored in the Catilist data base……

  5. Wayne Leach on March 9, 2013 8:47 AM

    “Every citizen has a right to keep and bear arms and this right shall never be questioned.” Maine Constitution, Article I, Section 16. Sounds pretty plain to me, so I will not even apply for a permit, and if anyone does an illegal search of my person or property, they will probably regret that, too. What is so complicated about the word NEVER?

  6. Ron Riml on March 10, 2013 10:50 PM

    Sportsman’s Alliance of Maine – Do you have some ‘links’ to this “Catilist’ database that you are referencing??

Leave A Reply

Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants

June 24, 2025

Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent

June 24, 2025

Three More Mills Vetoes – Tribal Eminent Domain, LGBTQIA+ Recovery Housing, Ferry Power Grab

June 24, 2025

China Tries Getting Rich In America’s Backyard

June 24, 2025

Rockland Police Search for Man in Connection to Reported Assault

June 24, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.