The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • About
  • Contact
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • GOP Wants Limits on “Net Energy Billing” to Rein in Electricity Rates
  • N.H. Residents Fear Maine “Trans Sanctuary” Bill Will Harm Granite State Kids: WGME
  • Critics of Drag Queen Story Hour Are “Perverts,” Says Bookstore Owner Who Wants Children at Her Drag Event
  • Out-of-State Firms Reaping Windfall Profits on Maine’s $220M Per Year Community Solar Program
  • Gov’t Watchdog Warns That COVID Aid Fraudsters Could Escape Jail Time
  • Largest Teachers Union Backs LGBTQ Group That Encourages Hiding Student Gender Changes
  • Maine State Police Shoot at Truck with Sign Indicating Explosive Device on Board at U.S.-Canada Border
  • Vandals Spray Paint “Corrupted” on Law Enforcement Memorial in Augusta Over Memorial Day Weekend
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Login
Wednesday, May 31
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • About
  • Contact
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Sigaud: Healthcare Prices not Reflective of Quality of Care
Commentary

Sigaud: Healthcare Prices not Reflective of Quality of Care

Liam SigaudBy Liam SigaudJanuary 15, 2016Updated:January 15, 2016No Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

If you’re like most people, you know very little about the costs of the medical services you receive.  The ubiquity of third-party payers in our health care system (be it private insurance carriers or the government through programs like Medicaid and Medicare), the complexity of billing practices and negotiated rates, and the resistance on the part of health care special interests against enhancing transparency have made it difficult for consumers to easily access cost information from medical providers.

A look at recently-released data from the Maine Health Data Organization shows a disturbing trend of massive (and seemingly arbitrary) health care cost variation between different providers in Maine – even between those in close proximity to each other.  Mercy Hospital in Portland, for instance, offers precancerous skin growth removal for an average of $117.  Less than a mile away, Maine Medical Center charges $551.  At Eastern Maine Medical Center, a knee replacement typically costs $47,233, while Saint Joseph’s Hospital – a 6-minute drive away – charges only $35,827.  Affiliated Labs, located in Portland, charges $11 for an electrolyte blood test while the same test at Maine Medical Center – just twelve minutes away – costs $101.  The list goes on.

Advocates for the health care industry have tried to justify these discrepancies by claiming that cost doesn’t properly capture the value of a medical service.  A low-cost procedure, they say, may not be as safe, nor the stay in the hospital as pleasant, as in a more expensive facility.  But according to an analysis by the Maine Heritage Policy Center, quality and patient satisfaction correlate poorly with health care prices in Maine.  Though available data regarding hospital-associated infection rates is sparse, the evidence suggests that as cost goes up, the quality of care and patient satisfaction ratings tend to decline.  Conversely, facilities that offer affordable prices often produce better outcomes and earn higher marks in patient satisfaction surveys.

It’s not difficult to explain these price disparities.  The absence of robust cost transparency (and mechanisms to motivate consumers to comparison shop for procedures) has allowed hospitals to set virtually whatever prices they like, confident that most of their patients won’t bother checking how much other providers charge.  Fierce competition, the most effective way to keep prices down, is all but non-existent in our health care industry.  At bottom, health care costs don’t reflect the value of a medical procedure – they indicate what hospitals think they can get away with.

A bill that will soon be voted on by the Legislature — LD 1305 — promises to bring greater transparency and competition to the health care market.  It requires providers to be more responsive to inquiries about the cost of services and offers financial incentives to patients who receive medical care at less than the average price, empowering consumers to save money while forcing providers to compete for lower prices.  In New Hampshire, where a similar program was instituted a few years ago, health care costs have already begun to decline as hospitals realize that arbitrary price-setting doesn’t work in a competitive, transparent market.

Featured healthcare Opinion
Previous ArticleStrout: How To Lower Prescription Drug Costs
Next Article FDA Bureaucracy Hinders Potentially Life-Saving Treatments
Liam Sigaud

Liam Sigaud is a former policy analyst at Maine Policy Institute. A native of Rockland, Maine, he holds a B.A. in Biology from the University of Maine at Augusta and has studied policy analysis and economics at the Muskie School of Public Service at the University of Southern Maine. He can be reached by email at liam.sigaud@maine.edu.

Related Posts

Press Herald Quotes Fake “Small Business Coalition” Without Disclosing Funding Ties to Liberal Dark Money Groups

May 26, 2023

Maine Mom Wonders What Would Happen Today to Tomboy Daughter: Letter

May 23, 2023

Old Town School Board Hits Pause Button on Proposed Transgender Policy

May 23, 2023

Leave A Reply

Recent News

GOP Wants Limits on “Net Energy Billing” to Rein in Electricity Rates

May 31, 2023

N.H. Residents Fear Maine “Trans Sanctuary” Bill Will Harm Granite State Kids: WGME

May 31, 2023

Critics of Drag Queen Story Hour Are “Perverts,” Says Bookstore Owner Who Wants Children at Her Drag Event

May 30, 2023

Out-of-State Firms Reaping Windfall Profits on Maine’s $220M Per Year Community Solar Program

May 30, 2023

Gov’t Watchdog Warns That COVID Aid Fraudsters Could Escape Jail Time

May 30, 2023
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Sign In or Register

Welcome Back!

Login below or Register Now.

Lost password?

Register Now!

Already registered? Login.

A password will be e-mailed to you.