The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Feds Charge Seven Chinese Nationals in Bay State Drug, Money Laundering, Smuggling Scheme
  • Lewiston Police Arrest Man for Possession of Sexually Explicit Material of a Child Under 12
  • Anti-ICE Activists Charged in Alleged Plot to Ambush Federal Officers, Shooting a Police Officer
  • Maine Supreme Court Reviewing Shenna Bellows’ Wording of Voter ID Referendum Question
  • Trump Strikes a Blow to Climate Agenda With Order Ending Subsidies for Solar, Wind, and Other ‘Renewables’
  • Murder Rap Catches Up to Maryland Fugitive Hiding in Auburn, Maine: U.S. Marshals
  • Laurel Libby’s Lawsuit Against Maine Speaker of the House Declared Moot After Her Rights Were Restored
  • Marine Patrol, Coast Guard Search for Missing Augusta Man Who Tried to Rescue His Dog in the Kennebec River
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Wednesday, July 9
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Commentary » Taxing Nonprofits Is Not Worth the Cost
Commentary

Taxing Nonprofits Is Not Worth the Cost

Ian RoyBy Ian RoyMarch 10, 2015Updated:March 10, 20152 Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

Voters and legislators across Maine are just beginning to sort through Governor LePage’s ambitious new tax reform package. While many of the aspects of the budget are promising, the proposal to allow municipalities to tax large nonprofits is ultimately counterproductive and will put an unnecessary strain on Maine communities.

To start, the concept of taxing large nonprofits (defined as those with assessed values over $500,000) is an inadequate replacement for the proposed elimination of state revenue sharing with municipalities. The $64 million per year that would normally flow to localities would have to either be made irrelevant by streamlining municipal services, or replaced by new sources of revenue. Property taxes are consistently the most convenient target.

While churches and smaller nonprofits will avoid this new tax, more prominent community institutions such as food pantries, hospitals, private schools and museums would now be subject to it.

The rationale provided by the administration so far is unconvincing. Supposedly the tax will be implemented in order to compensate the municipality “for providing infrastructure and services that nonprofits use but don’t pay for”.

While it is true that large nonprofits, particularly Universities and Hospitals, consume a great deal of local municipal services, the idea that nonprofits are broadly a greater strain than a benefit to communities is simply not true. The cost of a few plows and road salt cannot compare to the nearly 500,000 outpatient visits and nearly 100,000 emergency room visits that have been handled by the Maine Medical Center alone.

The cost of some road paint and stop signs cannot possibly compare to the number of hungry families and homeless individuals who are served by the 9 food pantries located just in Bangor, never mind throughout the rest of the state.

Conservatives understand the detrimental effects of high income and corporate taxes, as reflected in the LePage budget proposal.  They should similarly understand what would happen to many of these community-minded non-profits if they are suddenly subjected to taxes they are not currently paying.

A nonprofit is not a mystical, separate entity that can conjure up additional revenue to meet higher expenses; it is comprised of people. Employees, volunteers, services and customers are what make up a nonprofit, and these will have to incur any increase in taxes and operating expenses, to the detriment of those the non-profit serves.

The result of those additional expenses are unclear, but easy to conceptualize.  Clare Whitney from the Good Shepherd Food Bank in Auburn estimated that 100,000 fewer free meals would be distributed if the property taxes were to be implemented on her organization.  We will likely see a reduction of services, costs cut among human capital (jobs, salary) in the non-profit and in the case of Universities and museums, higher tuition and gate fees.

Ultimately, the existence of nonprofits that provide largely privately funded services is a positive force in Maine communities. It reduces the financial burdens on state resources and often delivers these services more efficiently and in a local, more responsive manner.

Instead of pursuing this policy pathway, state leaders and municipalities should explore other avenues in addressing the transition away from revenue sharing. The robust effort to make Maine a more competitive and growth-oriented state is laudable and welcomed, but making nonprofits with already razor thin margins shoulder the burden is not the ideal way of going about it.

budget Featured Maine Nonprofit Opinion Taxes
Previous ArticleSupreme Court Hears Oral Arguments in King v Burwell
Next Article College Savings Plans Should Be Expanded, Not Taxed
Ian Roy
  • Website

Ian Roy is the Director of Operations for I Am Created Equal. Earlier in his career, Ian was active with the organization Students for Liberty and interned in the Connecticut General Assembly on the Appropriations Committee. Originally from New England, Ian is a graduate from Temple University in Philadelphia.

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

(Screen Capture: PBS News Hour)

TRENT ENGLAND And JASON SNEAD: Time To Say Goodbye To Ranked Choice Voting

July 8, 2025

Bowdoin Graduate Zohran Mamdani and the Echoes of David Duke: Josh Filler

July 5, 2025

“What the F*&%!?” Janet Mills Freaks Out When Questioned Over Cocaine Use

July 4, 2025

<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="10002 http://www.themainewire.com/?p=10002">2 Comments

  1. Glen Hutchins on March 11, 2015 4:22 AM

    By not taxing non profits you are putting the tax burden on others, what happened to the lefts mantra of everyone pay their fair share? A business is a business , non profit or not and should be treated accordingly.

  2. David Printy on March 11, 2015 5:37 PM

    Many are missing a key point. Local boards need to be accountable for their total budgets. “Free” money from any state capital does not have the same citizen attention as their property tax. Each community can decide how much of the tax revenue they collect can be donated back to their local non-profits. Please remember Hospitals are major “businesses” and are paid for their services by individuals, Federal, State and company paid insurance. I have first hand knowledge of nonprofits sitting down with local Gov. Officials to workout a proper contribution to offset town expenses. Gov. LePage’s budget is focusing our attention on key issues that can have a very positive impact on the lives of all Mainers for years to come.
    We are most fortunate to have a Man of such courage with a real heart for the people of Maine serving as our Governor.

Leave A Reply

Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

Feds Charge Seven Chinese Nationals in Bay State Drug, Money Laundering, Smuggling Scheme

July 8, 2025

Lewiston Police Arrest Man for Possession of Sexually Explicit Material of a Child Under 12

July 8, 2025

Anti-ICE Activists Charged in Alleged Plot to Ambush Federal Officers, Shooting a Police Officer

July 8, 2025

Maine Supreme Court Reviewing Shenna Bellows’ Wording of Voter ID Referendum Question

July 8, 2025

Trump Strikes a Blow to Climate Agenda With Order Ending Subsidies for Solar, Wind, and Other ‘Renewables’

July 8, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.