The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • About
  • Contact
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Maine Wire Podcast: Carroll Conley on Abortion, LGBT, and Religious Liberty in Maine
  • Dems Block Debate on Gov’s Late-Term Abortion Bill, Refuse GOP Questioning of Medical Experts
  • Partisan Vote Ends Brakey’s Bid for Welfare Work Requirements
  • Democrats Block Parental Rights Policies, Including Bill to Let Parents “Opt Out” of Critical Race Theory Programming
  • White House Bracing for Supreme Court to Kill Student Loan Forgiveness Program: WSJ
  • State Legislature Poised to Pass Bill Establishing Home “Energy Scoring System” That Will Be Voluntary — For Now
  • Syrian Asylum Seeker Targets Children in Stabbing Spree at French Playground
  • Study Shows Nearly a Third of Gen Z Supports In-Home Government Surveillance Cameras
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Login
Thursday, June 8
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • About
  • Contact
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Ranked Choice Voting: Wrong for Maine & Blatantly Unconstitutional
Commentary

Ranked Choice Voting: Wrong for Maine & Blatantly Unconstitutional

Heather SirockiBy Heather SirockiMarch 29, 2016No Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

Until recently, I assumed that all measures placed on the ballot were lawful. I was wrong. Blatantly unconstitutional questions may appear on the ballot as long as enough valid signatures are certified by the Secretary of State.

In a detailed six-page legal opinion regarding the ranked-choice voting (RCV) ballot question, Attorney General Janet Mills concluded, “… that LD 1557 does raise significant constitutional concerns…”

Armed with the AG’s legal opinion, I am sounding the alarm – if passed, ranked-choice voting would likely face court challenges based on at least two violations to the Maine Constitution.

Elected officials are required to be sworn into office. This is a solemn ceremony. The vows involve specific emphasis on the State of Maine’s constitution. As one serving in the Maine House of Representatives since 2010, this is a promise I have made three times. I feel it is my duty and responsibility to uphold and defend the Constitution when I feel it is under attack.

As A.G. Mills explains, the ranked-choice voting ballot question calls into question Maine’s long-standing law requiring a plurality of votes to determine the winner of state races for governor, state senate, and representatives to the house. RCV would require that both state and federal races be determined by a majority vote rather than a plurality. Ranked–choice voting would trigger an instant runoff vote when a majority of votes is not met.

In plain terms, a plurality of votes means that the person with the most votes wins, while a majority of votes means 50% plus one vote is needed to determine the winner. The distinction between a plurality of votes and a majority of votes becomes important in races with more than two candidates.

The Maine Constitution also requires that ballots be tabulated and counted in local municipalities, but the ranked-choice voting proposal would involve transporting ballots to the Secretary of State’s office for instant runoff tabulations, which not only violates the Maine Constitution, but is also costly and time consuming.

Proponents insist that RCV is legal. If so, why do they want to delay implementation to 2018? And why has the League of Women Voters already drafted the amendments to change the constitution?

Interestingly, Maine’s original constitution did specify that a majority of votes were needed to win state races. Due to a hotly contested 3-way race for governor in 1879 in which a majority was not achieved, the Maine Constitution was amended in the 1880’s to its current form, whereby winners are determined by a plurality of votes.

Setting aside legal concern, let’s consider the merits of ranked-choice voting.

In races that involve more than two candidates, RCV allows the voter two options. The voter may bullet vote, which means they vote traditionally and select their favorite candidate, or they may rank their choices in order of preference.

If none of the candidates achieve a majority with more than 50% of the vote, then an instant runoff is triggered. The ballots that were cast for the candidate with the least amount of votes are re-tabulated. Any of the bullet votes are discarded, since they have already been applied to the loser. The loser’s voters that opted to rank their choices will have their ballots pulled and re-tabulated.

This means the ballots of the loser(s) will determine the winner. Some voters, the voters of the loser(s), would get to vote more than once.

Number crunchers have looked at RCV from many different angles, and some instant-runoff races could have different outcomes. Most races, however, end up with the same results – the person with the most votes still wins.

I have knocked on a lot of doors while campaigning. Many voters do not like politics, and they do not trust politicians. This concerns me because our form of government, a representative republic, depends on an informed and engaged citizenry. The element of trust is important.

How does changing to a confusing and difficult way of voting help the public feel more confident in those elected to represent them? Can an election be more easily rigged with bullet or ranked voting strategies? If ballots need to be transported for instant runoffs, are they more vulnerable to vote tampering?

In my opinion, the current methodology of determining the winner is clear- the person with the most votes wins.

Ranked-Choice Voting would:

  • violate the Maine Constitution in two ways – Plurality Requirement and Instant Runoff Tabulation Requirements
  • lead to costly court challenges
  • make Maine the only state in the nation to implement RCV
  • be costly to implement- an estimated $1.5 million for new equipment
  • also include the federal candidates running for U.S. Senate and House of Representatives, as well as Maine Governor, Maine Senate, and Maine Representatives to the House
  • involve instant recounts if there are more than two candidates that do not result in a majority vote
  • be time consuming
  • further disenfranchise voters by using the recounted ballots of the loser to determine the winner
attorney general mills Constitution Featured Opinion rank choice voting unconstitutional voting
Previous ArticleMaine Liberals Continue To Enable Sanctuary Cities
Next Article Should Maine Teachers Be Armed?
Heather Sirocki

State Representative Heather Sirocki represents Maine House District 28 including part of Scarborough. She sits on the Appropriations and Financial Affairs Committee and can be reached at Heather.Sirocki@legislature.maine.gov.

Related Posts

Question A Helps Fix the Mess Socialists Made in Portland

June 6, 2023

Flashback: BlackRock CEO Says Investment Firm Forces Companies to Change Behavior on Diversity with Threats of Impacts to Compensation

June 5, 2023

Democrats, Inequity, and Exclusion: Desjardin

June 5, 2023

Leave A Reply

Recent News

Maine Wire Podcast: Carroll Conley on Abortion, LGBT, and Religious Liberty in Maine

June 8, 2023

Dems Block Debate on Gov’s Late-Term Abortion Bill, Refuse GOP Questioning of Medical Experts

June 8, 2023

Partisan Vote Ends Brakey’s Bid for Welfare Work Requirements

June 8, 2023

Democrats Block Parental Rights Policies, Including Bill to Let Parents “Opt Out” of Critical Race Theory Programming

June 8, 2023

White House Bracing for Supreme Court to Kill Student Loan Forgiveness Program: WSJ

June 8, 2023
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Sign In or Register

Welcome Back!

Login below or Register Now.

Lost password?

Register Now!

Already registered? Login.

A password will be e-mailed to you.