The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Four Arrested in Brooks Drug Bust After Months-Long Investigation
  • Mills Wants to Keep the Door Open for “Future Generations” to Seize Tribal Lands
  • All Maine School Boards Have Just Over a Year to Decide on Their Student Cell Phone Use Policies
  • Nukes and Cukes: In Negotiating with Iran, the Patient and the Determined Always Have the Edge
  • Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants
  • Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent
  • Three More Mills Vetoes – Tribal Eminent Domain, LGBTQIA+ Recovery Housing, Ferry Power Grab
  • China Tries Getting Rich In America’s Backyard
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Wednesday, June 25
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Commentary » Does Maine really need a vehicle inspection program?
Commentary

Does Maine really need a vehicle inspection program?

Jacob PosikBy Jacob PosikDecember 4, 2017Updated:December 4, 2017No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Mechachic checking on a car engine and taking notes
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

The Portland Press Herald on Sunday, Nov. 26 published an article highlighting recent efforts in Maine to crack down on the black market of counterfeit vehicle inspection stickers. As noted in the article, a group of men in Saco were recently charged for producing and selling fake inspection stickers.

Lt. Bruce Scott, who helps oversee Maine’s vehicle inspection program, added the counterfeit stickers from the Saco bust to the “Fake Sticker Hall of Fame,” a board Scott uses to commemorate both the hideous and more authentic counterfeit stickers he and other law enforcement officials have encountered in their years of service.

Over the last two decades, 16 states have repealed their vehicle inspection programs. Today, Maine is one of just 17 states with annual or biannual vehicle inspection programs on the books, calling into question Maine’s need for the program.

Maine drivers spend an estimated $16 million to get their vehicles inspected each year. While vehicle inspections burden every Mainer, the program is particularly harmful to low-income earners who already struggle to pay the $15 inspection fee, let alone potentially hundreds of dollars in repairs to legally drive their vehicle on Maine roads.

The stated purpose of a vehicle inspection program is to ensure that vehicles driven on public roadways safe and do not pose a threat to drivers, passengers and other motorists. Proponents of vehicle inspections assert that the program is necessary for protecting the health and safety of everyone traveling on Maine roads. However, vehicles are inherently dangerous for a number of reasons, and the data does not back the assertion that inspections improve safety.

Using accident report data from 1981 to 1993, a study found that vehicle inspection programs do not reduce fatality rates or the number of nonfatal accidents. In addition, little evidence exists to suggest that motor vehicle accidents occur as a result of mechanical failure, which is what vehicle inspection programs are intended to prevent. A study by Utah’s Libertas Institute found that in 2013, only 3.8 percent of motor vehicle accidents in the state were due to mechanical failures. The majority of reported accidents were caused by speeding.

The Libertas study also notes, “Safety inspections administered based on the age of the car are an inaccurate way to measure a car’s usage, and therefore safety; a vehicle rarely or never driven should not need an inspection, and it is not worth the time to the inspection station or the vehicle owner to force an inspection.”

Despite the simple logic that a car that is rarely driven should not need inspection, Maine and other states still impose this requirement. In contrast, inspection programs present a timely opportunity for inspection stations to cash in on drivers whose vehicles accumulate mileage at above average rates (especially those with no automotive knowledge or expertise).

Requiring a vehicle to be inspected is also flawed because the inspection takes place only once every one or two years, offering just a snapshot of the vehicle’s overall condition and performance.

The presence of an inspection sticker does not guarantee the safety of a vehicle for any length of time. Instead, it merely informs law enforcement personnel that you have paid the mandatory fees required to operate a vehicle on public roadways for a one or two year period. The overall safety of a vehicle is dependent on the driver, road and weather conditions, and the quality of the mechanic(s) performing routine maintenance and annual inspections on the vehicle. Given the power inspections stations have over an individual’s right to drive on public roads, many Mainers are forced to pay hundreds of dollars each year for repairs and alterations that do not enhance the safety, mechanical performance, or reliability of their vehicles.

Based on the existing data, it is time for Maine to reconsider its vehicle inspection program. The costs incurred by every Mainer are not worth the fruitless “benefits” of the state’s inspection program, as it has shown no measurable improvement to the health and safety of Maine motorists in comparison to motorists in states that do not mandate vehicle inspections.

Instead of accentuating the “Hall of Fame” used to commemorate fraudulent stickers and patronize violators, Maine’s media should explore why a counterfeit operation like the one in Saco would exist to begin with; because Maine’s vehicle inspection program is a government protected racket that some Mainers simply cannot afford.

Commentary Featured inspection stickers vehicle inspections
Previous ArticleLet’s make sure gun control laws already on the books are working
Next Article Tax relief effort will benefit Maine families, workers, and small businesses
Jacob Posik

Jacob Posik, of Turner, is the director of legislative affairs at Maine Policy Institute. He formerly served as policy analyst and communications director at Maine Policy, as well as editor of the Maine Wire. Posik can be reached at jposik@mainepolicy.org.

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

Nukes and Cukes: In Negotiating with Iran, the Patient and the Determined Always Have the Edge

June 24, 2025

King 2.0 Out-Politics Pingree 2.0 on Her Home Turf at Rockland “No Kings” Rally

June 16, 2025

Maine Businesses Shouldn’t Have to Pick up the Tab for Northern Light Health’s Financial Problems

June 16, 2025

Leave A Reply

Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

Four Arrested in Brooks Drug Bust After Months-Long Investigation

June 24, 2025

Mills Wants to Keep the Door Open for “Future Generations” to Seize Tribal Lands

June 24, 2025

All Maine School Boards Have Just Over a Year to Decide on Their Student Cell Phone Use Policies

June 24, 2025

Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants

June 24, 2025

Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent

June 24, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.