M.D. Harmon: Time to stand our ground on "stand your ground"


The current ginned-up controversy over “stand your ground” laws in Florida and elsewhere is actually a testament to the growing influence of that portion of the civil liberties movement that is focused on the Second Amendment.

The chief, but certainly not the sole, agent of that growth in effectiveness is the National Rifle Association, of which I have been a member since 1967, when I took the proceeds of my first military paycheck and sent in the requisite $100 that a life membership then cost. (It was a fourth of my monthly gross pay, so it was a substantial amount.)

I’ve never regretted it for a second. Our liberties dealing with the right to keep and bear arms (which are rooted in the intrinsic human right to self-defense) are scorned by other so-called “civil liberties” groups (yes, I mean you, ACLU), so we need a dedicated organization to defend them against their attackers.

We wouldn’t have recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions that verified those rights exist, and apply nationwide, were not the NRA and others willing to bear the legal, moral and financial burdens of defending them. Such groups remain at the forefront of a double-barreled effort (sorry) to expand the reach of these liberties.

The first is to reach into those jurisdictions hostile to our rights to fight in court against the continued restrictions such communities and states (and bureaucracies at various levels) enact and try to enforce that are in violation of both the Court’s decisions and the application of those decisions to individual Americans.

Along that line, Second Amendment defenders are contesting the laws of New York and New Jersey, which are using local laws and court decisions to impinge on the rights of Americans to travel with secured firearms and ammunition, something federal law specifically permits.

Even trained military personnel have been charged and their weapons confiscated under these oppressive state policies and statutes, and new laws are being drafted in Congress to halt these abuses of our rights.

In other cases, anti-gun activists have tried to ban the use of lead in bullets via federal regulation, with the latest attempt turned back just this month. Such a ban would greatly increase the price of ammunition, making it difficult or impossible for hunters and target shooters to practice their preferred enthusiasms.

Other states have attempted to require that guns should be manufactured with the ability to “microstamp” bullets fired through them, to link a firearm with its expended rounds. This technology, which does not exist at present, would also be extremely expensive if it ever was developed, and raise the cost of new firearms far beyond the reach of most people, experts say.

Beyond opposing laws designed to harass ordinary gun owners and make criminals out of law-abiding people, gun-rights defenders also have aimed for decades at passing positive legislation that expands the reach of firearms’ rights, both with regard to sporting uses and with regard to their primary purpose, self-defense. (Americans use guns for defending themselves and their loved ones hundreds of thousands of times a year, if not more.)

Thus, gun clubs have been grandfathered into their locations and offered legal protection against neighbors (some of whom moved in knowing there was a gun club nearby) who complained of noise or traffic, or alleged that firearms’ discharges were hazards they deserved to be defended against, regardless of the adequacy of range safety measures.

More significantly, the right to bear arms outside of one’s residence has been strongly defended, resulting in all but one state (Illinois) allowing weapons to be carried outside the home. But the numbers and types of restrictions, including on “open carry” (with a weapon in plain sight) and concealed carry, vary widely. (The places with room for considerable improvement besides Illinois include Massachusetts, New York and New Jersey).

Guns rights defenders in both parties in Congress are working hard to get a law passed to treat concealed weapons permits like drivers’ licenses, in that each state that offered them would have to recognize those of other states, although individual state laws would apply to the circumstances of carry within each jurisdiction. The law is very popular, but will probably have to await the election of a new president to avoid a veto from the current one.

Four states — Alaska, Vermont, Arizona and Wyoming — require no license at all to carry a firearm, either openly or concealed, and Maine is one of many “shall-issue” states where guns may be carried openly and concealed carry permits may only be denied for reasons specifically laid out in law (and not at some official’s whim, as is the case in some of the places mentioned above).

So, felons, the certified mentally ill and spouse abusers may not carry weapons, but every other adult may, including carrying concealed as long as training and registration requirements are met.

We’ve all seen how foolish “No Guns Allowed” policies are, disarming law-abiding people while opening up schools and other public places to those who are willing to break the law because they deliberately intend to attack the defenseless.

The most notable recent addition to the positive side of the law regarding firearms possession and use are so-called “castle laws” and “stand-your-ground laws,” the latter much in the news because of the death of a teenager in Florida at the hands of an armed member of a neighborhood watch group.

Briefly, because many state laws and legal precedents had established that crime victims had what was called a “duty to retreat” when violence was threatened against them, people had to prove that they were essentially cornered and unable to escape before they could use force to defend their persons or property. Or, they had to flee their own homes if they were able.

Because this state of affairs was widely (and correctly) seen as unjust, privileging criminals and punishing victims, many states passed laws saying there was no duty to retreat if you were in your own place of residence. These were known as “castle laws” from “a man’s home is his castle.”

But that “duty” to run away was still being applied to victims threatened or attacked in public, even in places where those citizens had every legal right to be — parks, sidewalks, parking lots, yards, etc.

That was true even though, as long ago as 1895, the U.S. Supreme Court had ruled in Beard v. U.S. that an innocent person under attack was “not obligated to retreat, but was entitled to stand his ground, and meet any attack on him with a deadly weapon…”

“Stand your ground laws” thus extended the right of self-defense to those public places, on the solid moral ground that criminals should not have the power to force law-abiding citizens to flee from locations where they were breaking no law and had every right to remain. Janet Napolitano, now the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, signed such a law when she was governor of Arizona.

So it seems odd that people would resist such laws, because there is no reason to make criminals a privileged group. That would be — well, criminal.

Of course, long before anyone, beyond the people directly involved, knows what really happened in the Florida case, anti-gun groups are blaming that state’s stand-your-ground law for the shooting of an innocent person.

Numerous legal experts have pointed out, however, that no matter what happened, the law is not at fault. If George Zimmerman, the admitted shooter, confronted Treyvon Martin, the teenager, after following him, he wasn’t standing his ground under the law’s definition.

And if, as he tells it, he had left off following Martin and was returning to his car when he was attacked and then defended himself, he was acting within his rights under the law.

Either way, the law isn’t the issue, and shouldn’t be criticized as if it were. Efforts to overturn such statutes should be seen as exactly what they are – efforts to turn public places back over to the control of the worst among us, and make everyone else give way to them. Or, more likely, become their victims once again.

We’ve had enough of that. The just-concluded NRA annual convention had more than 75,000 attendees, a record. Let’s show the crooks’ defenders (some of whom are crooks themselves) that most Americans will stand our ground on “stand your ground.”

Speaking of which, isn’t it time Maine had such a law?

M.D. Harmon, a retired journalist and military officer, is a free-lance writer. He can be contacted at mdharmoncol@yahoo.com.


  1. As a retired LEO I always carry a gun.  I have never felt threatened by a law abiding (thats the important part)  citizen with a gun in 29 yrs of service.  If you outlaw firearms you just make the job of murderers, rapist,muggers and  all the crooked politicans, safer

  2. I completely agree. As retired military, I have a concealed carry permit and will not hesitate to draw my weapon to defend myself or my family if threatened by a criminal offender. I would do this with the full knowledge that leftist and Marxist organizations such as Shenna Bellows of the MCLU, the Maine People’s Alliance and the Maine Equal Justice Partners would immediately classify me as the criminal and the criminal as the victim. I would be villified in the editorials of the Pingree Peoples Herald and the BDN. All so the leftist anti-liberty organisations can promote their agendas. These organisations want us to be docile sheep who will blindly follow their every command. I, for one, will never succumb to their agenda. As Charlton Heston said, ‘ from my cold, dead hands…….!’

  3. Let’s not get too far aheade of this thing. If the trial of the shooter in Florida turns up facts that he wasn’t just” standing his gound” but had used and abused that law to hios own end, then we all have egg on our face. Stand you ground should should always be our right but let’ s not create our own trap.

  4. I agree with Mr. Harmon that Maine does need a “Stand your ground law” so that someone who is defending him or herself from an attacker outside one’s home does not become the criminal. A thug who attacks a smaller man, an elderly person, or a woman with criminak intent should not become the “victim” if those people defend themselves from attack with a legal weapon. Sometimes you cannot run from a younger, stronger, or better armed aggressor. You may be forced to “stand your ground” to survive. That shouldn’t make you a criminal just because you find yourself confronted in a public park or a public street.

  5. Would I uncivil to suggest that liberals seem to have an instinctive preference for a passive, dependent and obedient citizenry?

    Another point:  I used to teach my political science classes that the NRA is actually the largest consumer advocacy group in the U.S. and has the almost unique characteristic among such advocacy groups  of being made up of actual consumers of the goods it advocates for.

  6. We dont need laws that exempt Murderers from prosecution because they are the “Last Man Standing”

    These laws enable murderers to go free just on their ‘Claim” of self defense.

       The Victums are being robbed of their right to due process of the law!
      The Second Amendment may give the right to Bare Arms but it doesn’t transcend to to violate the  rights of the victum.

    { The Dead can not speak and defend their position! }

    Therefore every Death by Force needs to be treated as Criminal Homicide to protect their rights!

  7. It’s just like you examine my head! You seem to know a great deal about it, just like you authored the publication inside or something like that. I have faith that you could do with just a few delaware. chemical. to help strength the solution property a tad, having said that other than that, that is wonderful site. An awesome read through. I’m going to surely be back.

  8. dates. On this page all of us may design 8 ideas which many years associated with encounter, a large number of types as well as countless enrollment procedures possess trained all of us. Should you put into action just a few of these, then you might find a greater quantity of your own candidates finishing your own enrollment precisely as well as promptly. As well as in the end, that is exactly what it is about! 1. Determine what is important — Where to begin whenever climbing lower as well as streamlining the application is actually determining the info you’ll want out of your candidate. Be sure you place which info within the very first type or even 2 you’re requesting these phones complete. This way when they disappear next, you have the fundamental data you’ll need. Requesting an excessive amount of may backfire you. Through requesting queries you do not always require the solution in order to, you may end up receiving individuals ineffective solutions more than info that’s vital as well as useful. Making a credit card applicatoin which strategically as well as realistically provides you with the actual solutions you’ll need may internet what is most significant and you will invest much less period investigating the info you actually worth. two. Split this Upward In to Phases — This seems far better to begin a credit card applicatoin viewing that we now have just 2 or 3 types or even areas to accomplish instead of 10. Candidates which observe a number of types immediately could possibly get discouraged or even overcome. From greatest, they’ll inform on their own that they’ll reach this later on (and in no way will��). From most detrimental, they’ll depart prior to these people actually begin. After you have your own candidates involved you can include another phases for their software procedure because they complement. At this time, they’ll be much more prepared to carry on with the procedure because they have spent time and effort involved with it. Bear in mind! There’s a sensitive stability right here!

    [url=http://www.solgaardsparken.dk/favion.asp]Gamma Blue 11s[/url]

    ing else. So that they can keep to going usually there are some guidelines to generate the earliest very few flows more fun right until your cycle is definitely bought. The earliest a person will almost certainly good crazy specifically starters it is very important around allowing this online game with performing a rational prospect. This initially rule will be to perform personally tiny to get any time you get out. Against your initially consider you actually go with about a minute. That is definitely them. In that case continue to keep move in the nominal stride unless you want to reach the span of time and also yardage that you were targeting. The next time you are going to add to the be not one but two a matter of minutes et cetera unless you want to will be against your thirtieth working day going for your 100 % half an hour. Our next rule will be to natural make a note of just what exactly you are searching so that you can be free from going. Do you find it losing weight, muscle, flexibleness or even perform some initial time frame and also fuel consumption rate? The key reason why it is very important you’re going is required to be authored all the way down to get test typically. Better the simple truth is a intention around dark colored around white colored, a lot more likely its you comply with acquiring these folks. Commitment is used up immediately. The fact is following on from the initially weeks time our bodies is definitely blister, you just aren’t witnessing every success plus you can certainly fail to remember the key reason why you actually going. Aim to switch a person’s workout, perform by using associates, pay for quite a few innovative going supplies and also posting commitment sentences all over you continue to keep you actually stimulated. A intention is definitely being a athlete for all his life. That isn’t a little level it is a innovative chosen lifestyle. In this that they are real it is very important to not ever overdo them. Begin with continual, really don’t obliterate you. You ma

    [url=http://www.solgaardsparken.dk/favion.asp]Bottom price Sport Blue 3s 2014[/url]

    Seeing that anyone a�? took upa�? your cultural game involving the game of golf you could possibly effectively get a number of concerns. The game of golf along with the game of golf is often a nearly all wonderful cultural game. You are free to even though out a long time, conferring while using the game of golf green veggies together with your pals for the the game. Ita�? ersus an awesome, comforting interest. Also most of businessa�? ersus a�? major dealsa�? along with organization contact lenses could effectively be generated the game of golf along with for the the game also inside the game club. Currently that you’ve thought we would become a member of your interest involving the game of golf precisely what in fact include the principles involving the game of golf? Firstly m normal list of the game of golf along with the game of golf golf equipment involves about three a�? woodsa�? golf sets. These kind of about three woodlands as well as a�? driversa�? encompass your a�? drivera�?, a�? three-wooda�? along with a�? five-wooda�?. Up coming throughout range, inside information involving normal golf sets include the a�? ironsa�?. Your teams of your a�? ironsa�? gang of golf sets normally are comprised in the three-iron, five-iron, six-iron, seven-iron, eight-iron, nine-iron, pitching iron wedge lastly your most renowned golf-club, using which in turn to generate your current closing picture in the the game of golf glass for the the game of golf natural. Relating your rigorous regulations involving the game of golf you are unable to hold over 18 golf equipment
    to appearance and feel just like. Retain exercising with your a couple of golf clubs due to the fact once you ultimately ensure it is on the particular greens, these kinds of could be the golf clubs in which can save you several any playing golf photo and also reduce your playing golf report.The game of golf Along with The game of golf For starters â € “ Your current Standard The game of golf Handbag

    [url=http://www.jenskokholm.dk/index.html]bred 11s[/url]

    Related Links: http://beckersforhandlere.net/iconf.html

  9. Soon after study a number of of the weblog posts on your web page now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site list and will likely be checking back soon. Pls have a look at my internet site as well and let me know what you believe.
    retro jordan 4

  10. When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get 4 emails using the same comment. Is there any way you could eliminate me from that service? Thanks!
    cheap jordans

  11. When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now every time a comment is added I get four emails using the very same comment. Is there any way it is possible to eliminate me from that service? Thanks!
    jordans for cheap

  12. There are certainly lots of details like that to take into consideration. Which is an incredible point to bring up. I give the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly one can find questions like the 1 you bring up where probably the most necessary factor is going to be working in honest superior faith. I don?t know if most beneficial practices have emerged around issues like that, but I am sure that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls feel the impact of just a moment’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.
    cheap jordan shoes


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here