The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • About
  • Contact
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Competitive Shooting Event to Raise More Than $75k for Travis Mills Foundation with USPSA Maine State Championship
  • GOP Wants Limits on “Net Energy Billing” to Rein in Electricity Rates
  • N.H. Residents Fear Maine “Trans Sanctuary” Bill Will Harm Granite State Kids: WGME
  • Critics of Drag Queen Story Hour Are “Perverts,” Says Bookstore Owner Who Wants Children at Her Drag Event
  • Out-of-State Firms Reaping Windfall Profits on Maine’s $220M Per Year Community Solar Program
  • Gov’t Watchdog Warns That COVID Aid Fraudsters Could Escape Jail Time
  • Largest Teachers Union Backs LGBTQ Group That Encourages Hiding Student Gender Changes
  • Maine State Police Shoot at Truck with Sign Indicating Explosive Device on Board at U.S.-Canada Border
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Login
Wednesday, May 31
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • About
  • Contact
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Tobacco tax increase would reduce revenue, hurt the poor and undermine safe alternatives
News

Tobacco tax increase would reduce revenue, hurt the poor and undermine safe alternatives

Michael MaddenBy Michael MaddenApril 19, 2021Updated:April 19, 2021No Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

The 100 percent increase in taxes on all tobacco products as proposed recently in the State legislature (LD 1423) doubles down on Maine’s regressive and all-inclusive tobacco tax structure, puts fuel on the State’s already flourishing illicit tobacco trade, and, perhaps most importantly, ignores the science on true tobacco harm reduction. 

The bill ostensibly seeks to decrease adult cigarette smoking and increase funding for tobacco control and heath disparities research. Unfortunately, State law mandates that when cigarette taxes are increased, taxes on all other tobacco products, including moist snuff and vapor products – which are substantially safer than cigarettes – must also be increased by the same percentage. 

So, the 100 percent increase in the cigarette tax means the taxes on both moist snuff (oral tobacco) and vapor products are also doubled. This makes the tax on all e-cigarette or vapor products 86 percent of their wholesale cost: the second highest tax on nicotine vapor products in the country. And despite the magnitude of this tax increase, it is unclear whether State legislators have considered its sweeping impact.

Tobacco taxes are inherently regressive (because low-income people pay a higher percentage of their income in taxes), as smokers are disproportionately lower income. The bill burdens this group with a 100 percent tax increase without considering all of the consequences of that action.

Maine’s tobacco taxation structure should reflect a science-backed tobacco harm reduction policy. Harm reduction is a key public-health principle employed to mitigate health risks. Tobacco harm reduction equals a broad array of non-combustible tobacco products (vapor, SNUS, and moist tobacco). A body of evidence from leading health authorities indicates that vapor products are significantly less harmful than cigarettes, and decades of scientific research have established that oral tobacco products pose substantially fewer health risks to users than cigarettes. 

Logically, if tobacco products that are significantly less harmful than cigarettes are also significantly less expensive than cigarettes, today’s smokers will be more likely to use the safer products, either to help them quit or to transition to an acceptable substitute. 

Furthermore, a 100 percent increase in taxes on all tobacco products will undoubtedly drive both organized and casual smuggling of cigarettes into Maine. Maine’s neighbor, New Hampshire, already reaps tens of millions of dollars in tobacco tax revenues from cigarettes purchased there and carried to neighboring states. 

If LD 1423 becomes law, the disparity in the price of a pack of cigarettes in Maine versus New Hampshire will be more than $2 per pack.  With more than half of the population of Maine living within roughly an hour’s drive of the New Hampshire border, it must be anticipated that many of the State’s smokers will simply purchase their cigarettes elsewhere. 

Even more dangerous, organized criminals already reap the benefits of a substantial illicit cigarette trade bringing truckloads of cigarettes bought in other, cheaper states in the South to high-tax states like New York and Massachusetts. Both organized and causal smuggling will rob Maine of the tax revenue the bill hopes to gain, and one can be certain that those dealing in illegal tobacco products will not care about keeping these products out of the hands of youth.

The implications of raising tobacco taxes are complex. If the true goal is improved health and reduced disparities among socioeconomic groups, it must be handled with care and with an eye toward the foreseeable consequences. Simply demanding that some of Maine’s most vulnerable groups swallow a 100 percent tax increase is short-sighted and dangerous.  LD 1423 is the wrong bill for the health and safety of today’s smokers, and of all Mainers.

cigarettes Commentary ecigarette Featured sin tax smoking smoking cessation Taxes tobacco tobacco tax
Previous ArticleWhere’s Dr. Fauci as another corona-myth dies?
Next Article New England governors are lifting pandemic mandates, but not Governor Mills
Michael Madden

Dr. Madden is a family physician and former chief medical officer of a multi-state Medicaid health plan. He's also a consultant with RAI Services Company on issues related to tobacco harm reduction.

Related Posts

Competitive Shooting Event to Raise More Than $75k for Travis Mills Foundation with USPSA Maine State Championship

May 31, 2023

GOP Wants Limits on “Net Energy Billing” to Rein in Electricity Rates

May 31, 2023

N.H. Residents Fear Maine “Trans Sanctuary” Bill Will Harm Granite State Kids: WGME

May 31, 2023

Leave A Reply

Recent News

Competitive Shooting Event to Raise More Than $75k for Travis Mills Foundation with USPSA Maine State Championship

May 31, 2023

GOP Wants Limits on “Net Energy Billing” to Rein in Electricity Rates

May 31, 2023

N.H. Residents Fear Maine “Trans Sanctuary” Bill Will Harm Granite State Kids: WGME

May 31, 2023

Critics of Drag Queen Story Hour Are “Perverts,” Says Bookstore Owner Who Wants Children at Her Drag Event

May 30, 2023

Out-of-State Firms Reaping Windfall Profits on Maine’s $220M Per Year Community Solar Program

May 30, 2023
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Sign In or Register

Welcome Back!

Login below or Register Now.

Lost password?

Register Now!

Already registered? Login.

A password will be e-mailed to you.