The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Four Arrested in Brooks Drug Bust After Months-Long Investigation
  • Mills Wants to Keep the Door Open for “Future Generations” to Seize Tribal Lands
  • All Maine School Boards Have Just Over a Year to Decide on Their Student Cell Phone Use Policies
  • Nukes and Cukes: In Negotiating with Iran, the Patient and the Determined Always Have the Edge
  • Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants
  • Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent
  • Three More Mills Vetoes – Tribal Eminent Domain, LGBTQIA+ Recovery Housing, Ferry Power Grab
  • China Tries Getting Rich In America’s Backyard
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Wednesday, June 25
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
The Maine Wire
Home » News » News » Portland City Officials Express Public Health and Safety Concerns Over Proposal to Allow Homeless Camps in Public Spaces
News

Portland City Officials Express Public Health and Safety Concerns Over Proposal to Allow Homeless Camps in Public Spaces

Edward TomicBy Edward TomicNovember 13, 2023Updated:November 13, 20232 Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

The Portland City Council is set to consider Monday a proposed order that would amend city ordinances to allow homeless individuals to camp and loiter in public spaces, with few exceptions.

The order, submitted by City Councilors Anna Trevorrow and Roberto Rodriguez, would create a “temporary exception to the City’s prohibition on camping and loitering on City property and would allow unhoused people to camp on certain public property from the
effective date of the amendments to April 30, 2024.”

The proposed amendment changes would maintain a prohibition on camping in certain specified locations, including downtown streets and sidewalks, playgrounds, City Hall Plaza, Monument Square, and within 250 feet of schools.

The push to effectively legalize homeless encampments has been met with broad resistance.

In memos submitted to the City Council in advance of their first reading of the proposal, the Portland Police Department, the Departments of Health and Human Services (DHHS), Parks, Recreation and Facilities, and Housing and Economic Development all identified their concerns with the anticipated impacts of the order on public health and safety.

[RELATED: Portland May Legalize Loitering, Camping in Parks for Homeless Population…]

Portland DHHS Public Health Director Alfredo Vergara recommended against the City Council moving forward with the proposed ordinance changes, citing in his memo numerous public health risks posed by homeless encampments.

The health risks of homeless encampments listed by Vergara include the increased transmission of infectious diseases from dirty needles such as HIV and Hepatitis C and A, the lack of sanitation with food and water, potential transmission of diseases borne by rodents, birds, and other animals, and the lack of human waste disposal.

Vergara also identified the encampments’ exposure to extreme weather conditions, fire hazards, lack of easy access to healthcare, and violence as reasons for the DHHS recommendation against the proposal.

“As the largest public health risks in encampments revolve around infectious disease and other hazards resulting from poor hygiene, and due to the inability to provide sufficient services and resources to mitigate these issues, it is the public health recommendation to not move forward with the current proposed ordinance changes,” Vergara wrote.

Ethan Hipple, Director of Portland’s Department of Parks, Recreation and Facilities, wrote in his memo to the City Council that the proposed ordinance changes “would result in the degradation and long term damage of public spaces, decrease ADA accessibility and safe pedestrian transportation, and lower the overall quality of life in Portland.”

“The proposed changes will also prolong inhumane and dangerous living conditions for the unhoused, and hazardous working conditions for City staff,” Hipple added.

Hipple describes how similar approaches to homeless encampments in Portland, Oregon, San Francisco, and Denver, Colorado have “proven disastrous,” saying that these cities “are now reversing course and working to increase enforcement efforts so that these cities remain livable and sustainable for all.”

“As we have seen in Portland and elsewhere around the country, entrenched encampments are incompatible with the safe and healthy use of a park by all populations,” he wrote.

[RELATED: Taxpayers Have Spent More Than $114 Million on Portland Homeless Shelters Since 2019…]

Portland Chief of Police Mark Dubois described similar public health and safety concerns in his memo to the Council.

Allowing camping and loitering on sidewalks, Dubois wrote, creates “a significant risk of hazard to both campers and pedestrians trying to navigate the city’s sidewalks.”

Dubois wrote that although there is a provision in the proposed ordinance changes to allow police to clear an obstruction, pedestrians would likely have to step into the roadway to avoid campers and their belongings.

The Portland Police Chief also identified the risk posed to campers by snow being plowed from the roadways during the winter.

Director of the Portland Department of Public Works Michael Murray also cited snow removal as a significant concern.

“The additional obstacle of campsites along the right of way would limit DPW operators’ ability to remove snow and maintain navigable roads for drivers and pedestrians; travel lanes would be narrowed, creating a significant threat of injury or death to persons in the campsites/encampments over the course of plowing events,” Murray wrote.

Additional cause for concern, according to Dubois, is the proximity of homeless encampments to businesses that would be allowed under the ordinance changes.

One proposed ordinance change would allow camping, sleeping, and loitering in “the front or immediate area of any store, shop, restaurant, tavern or other place of business…”

“Allowing these activities in such close proximity to businesses would invite negative interactions between campers, business owners, and patrons, and a drastic increase in calls for service related to activities frequently associated with encampments,” Dubois wrote.

Dubois added that under current conditions, Portland Police responds to “multiple such calls daily,” and would expect that number to increase if the proposed ordinance changes are passed.

Following the city’s sweep of the homeless encampment at the Marginal Way Park and Ride on Nov. 1, the largest encampment in the city is now located underneath the Casco Bay Bridge.

[RELATED: Sweep Underway at Portland’s Largest Homeless Encampment, Being Moved Below Casco Bay Bridge…]

Mary Davis, interim director of the Portland Housing and Economic Development Department, and Waterfront Coordinator Bill Needelman, wrote in a joint memo to the Council that camping on the waterfront area could put the homeless at risk of flooding, exposure to extreme coastal weather, and drowning.

Additionally, the proliferation of waterfront encampments that may come as a result of passing the proposed ordinance changes “may do long term harm to the positive economic impact of the waterfront economy,” Davis and Needelman wrote.

Davis and Needelman also expressed concerns over health hazards, an increase in thefts, and the encampments’ proximity to businesses being a deterrent to costumers.

Previous ArticleUPDATE: Janet Mills’ Independent Commission on Lewiston Shooting Will be Subject to FOAA After Release of Final Report, Mills Spox Says
Next Article Proposed Bill Lifting Cap on Virtual Charter School Enrollment Rejected by Democrat Lawmakers
Edward Tomic

Edward Tomic is a reporter for The Maine Wire based in Southern Maine. He grew up near Boston, Massachusetts and is a graduate of Boston University. He can be reached at tomic@themainewire.com

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

Four Arrested in Brooks Drug Bust After Months-Long Investigation

June 24, 2025

Mills Wants to Keep the Door Open for “Future Generations” to Seize Tribal Lands

June 24, 2025

All Maine School Boards Have Just Over a Year to Decide on Their Student Cell Phone Use Policies

June 24, 2025

<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="23272 https://www.themainewire.com/?p=23272">2 Comments

  1. A Jones on November 13, 2023 2:20 PM

    A Maine Department of Health and Human Services license is required to conduct, control, manage or operate, for compensation, any camping park or event camping. Examples include, but are not limited to:

    Tent Campgrounds,
    Recreational vehicle Campgrounds,
    Wilderness recreational parks,
    Agricultural fair Campgrounds,
    Event Camping.and
    Drug Campgrounds in just about EVERY place in Maine

    Show me YOUR PERMITS to operate a campground Portland, Bangor, Disgusta etc,etc,etc.

  2. Salvatore Mintz on November 13, 2023 2:32 PM

    Yes — this works soooo well everywhere else…

    Considering? Consider pulling your heads out of your a$$’s You obviously need to have a max IQ of 60 to be on the City Council.

    No, no and no. Stop the stupidity.

Leave A Reply

Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

Four Arrested in Brooks Drug Bust After Months-Long Investigation

June 24, 2025

Mills Wants to Keep the Door Open for “Future Generations” to Seize Tribal Lands

June 24, 2025

All Maine School Boards Have Just Over a Year to Decide on Their Student Cell Phone Use Policies

June 24, 2025

Supreme Court Hands Trump Admin Victory On Efforts To Deport ‘Worst’ Illegal Migrants

June 24, 2025

Oxford Senator Rick Bennett Sheds GOP to Run for Maine Governor as an Independent

June 24, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.