M.D. Harmon: Governor LePage used the wrong word to express a justified outrage

45
4

Gov. Paul LePage has said he was sorry for his comment likening the Internal Revenue Service to the “Gestapo” (in the IRS’ new role as the collector of taxes owed in lieu of buying health insurance under Obamacare).

Since the history of the Geheime Staatspolizei (“Secret State Police”) is one of terror, blood and death using techniques of unspeakable horror in the service of a brutal tyranny, he had no choice but to backtrack on the specific reference.

Too many people are still around who suffered, or whose forebears suffered, at the hands of Hitler’s evil minions. Such people did not deserve to have their memories rubbed raw by such a reference.

Still, any reasonable person (by that I exclude the liberal critics always looking for a chance to pig pile on a conservative governor) can see that there’s no way in the world LePage, by all accounts a personally generous and caring man, meant a literal comparison between the often-abusive IRS and an agency of Nazism.

We’ll look at what might have justifiably riled him in a bit more detail, but first I want to explore some left-wing hypocrisy on the issue of brutal agents of dictatorships.

Recall that hypocrisy is not defined as “having high personal standards and then violating them due to human weakness.” As columnist Jonah Goldberg has often pointed out, if that were the case, the only people incapable of hypocrisy would be those who had no standards at all, since everyone who does profess them fails from time to time to live up to them.

That’s not hypocrisy, it’s our flawed human nature tripping us up. If you want examples, both the Bible and secular histories are full of descriptive accounts beginning at the dawn of time.

No, true hypocrisy is instead citing standards you don’t yourself believe in or practice, and then using them to berate others.

LePage was wrong to use the word he did, but he wasn’t wrong to try to find strong language to condemn what the Patient Deception and Unaffordable Care Act aims to do those who won’t ante up for its requirements for individual mandatory coverage.

True, the penalty payment starts off small, $695 for a single person when it reaches its currently scheduled maximum in 2016, but it will grow.

In the meantime, the only mechanism the law cites for its enforcement is to withhold it from tax rebates. Since that will let many off the hook entirely, expect that to be changed if the law endures past the next election.

In discussing the utter disingenuousness of liberal criticism of LePage, however, remember that the governor’s intent was to criticize an unjustifiable intrusion of state power into the lives of Americans.

Liberals are great defenders of “choice” when it involves wiping out the life of an unborn baby, but when it comes to deciding not to buy insurance, they’re happy to toss the whole idea overboard.

But there’s more. How many conservatives have you ever seen wearing those nearly-ubiquitous-on-college-campuses T-shirts with pictures of a wavy-locked Che Guevara wearing a beret with a red star?

None, I’ll bet. They’re worn exclusively either by naïve innocents or by solid leftists, without any criticism from people on that side of the partisan divide. And when they are worn intentionally, their intent is not to condemn this vicious, brutal, murdering Communist, but to celebrate him.

Indeed, in the history of tyrannies, the red star and the swastika are equivalent symbols. How many of our students are taught that far more people have died at the hands of Marxist regimes than Hitler came close to killing, even though his regime’s slaughters were many and merciless?

Lenin and Stalin and Mao and Pol Pot and Ho Chi Minh made him a piker, however, and people like Cuba’s Castro and agents like Guevara added the shed blood of their victims to the ocean of blood spilled in the name of communism all over the world.

Yet, no one but a neo-Nazi fanatic would be seen displaying a hakenkreuz, Hitler’s “crooked cross” (which actually was an ancient Hindu and Buddhist symbol appropriated by him to denote supposed “Aryan racial purity”).

But red stars and Che romanticism abound on Americans’ chests to this day, perhaps through ignorance for many, but for some as symbols of an historic creed they secretly (or perhaps not so secretly) admire.

Thus, it is pure hypocrisy to call LePage names for going overboard with a word he intended as a condemnation, when they themselves are silent about — or even supportive of — symbols and figures whose record is steeped in the blood of innocents by the multiple tens of millions.

Let’s move on to the question of the IRS and the tax code itself, and whether LePage was right to say its excesses were enough to make you “angry.”

Ten years ago, the libertarian Cato Institute listed “Top Ten Civil Liberties Abuses of the Income Tax,” and they are still as true today as they were then (hat tip to Norm Linnell for informing me about this). The full article is worth searching for to read in its entirety, but here are some “lowlights”:

— The code violates the equal protection of the law by both “vertical” and “horizontal” inequity, taxing people with different incomes at different rates and then, due to a variety of exemptions and exclusions, also taxing many people with the same incomes at different rates.

— The tax code is also “complex, ambiguous and uncertain,” to the point where those seeking advice from the IRS itself about its strictures can often get incorrect or conflicting advice. Also, it is “unstable,” changing from year to year as Congress and the president tweak it to favor some and disfavor others.

— Taxpayers are denied due process, forced into administrative proceedings without a jury trial until a long and expensive appeals process is exhausted; they give up any rights of privacy and are compelled to disclose personal information that may be shared among many agencies; they bear the burden of proving their innocence when their accusers say they have violated the code; they are subjected to unreasonable searches and seizures when their assets are confiscated in advance of court judgments, often leaving them without resources to live on; and they are forced to incriminate themselves by providing potentially damaging data to the IRS under penalty of perjury.

Now, not all this is the IRS’ fault. Congress sets the code’s provisions, although there’s no doubt the IRS is punctilious about enforcing it even on those who ability to understand or live up to all its thousands upon thousands of provisions is extremely limited.

Is that enough to make someone angry? One might instead wonder why more people are not outraged.

M.D. Harmon, a retired journalist and military officer, is a free-lance writer. He can be contacted at: mdharmoncol@yahoo.com

45 COMMENTS

  1. The term has come to be used generically and unfortunately by many to mean “by force” ie, food gestapo; style gestapo, etc. No great outrage is expressed usually and especially unless it is a conservative and particularly Gov. LePage. There was no such outrage when the current President compared his bowling or whatever to “the Special Olympics.” The problem as I see it is: no matter what Governor LePage says, since is a plain speaking real person from Maine, he will be mocked and criticized by the folks from away who have chosen to take over the state of Maine.

  2. exactly, since I have paid my health care providers out of my savings account, why do I now have to send the IRS a check simply because I pay cash and choose not to carry insurance? In my opinion this is very simply a erosion of my freedom to choose what works best for my situation  while being forced to pay the IRS a additional tax for the right to do so

  3. Hi!

    It is refreshing to have a Governor finally say it like it is.

    I would have preferred though that he not used the words “God damn” on the air referring to his comment about the IRS being a gestapo but I forgive him.

    The IRS has been abusive and continues to be abusive (gestapo) with some of their tactics, and furthermore, the IRS was NEVER created by
    Congress but rather it was created by a “flick of a pen.”

    Check it out yourself.

  4. Deflecting a conversation about the manner in which the Governor of the State of Maine chose to depict the Internal Revenue Service and the first serious attempt the Congress of the United State has made to reform the healthcare policy in our country is, I suppose, appropriate to some.

    But the country isn’t talking about tee-shirts worn by extremists nor about “wiping out the life of an unborn baby” (where the heck did THAT come from?). They’re talking about the Governor of our state.

    The simple point is that Paul LePage, in spite of numerous admonitions, continues to demonstrate his inept understanding of statesmanship.

    This time, it was calculated. It wasn’t an off-hand quip. It wasn’t a thoughtless reaction in the heat of the moment. Our state’s chief executive went to his vile wordsmithing closet and chose to insert a heinous invective into what should have been a reasoned (albeit negative) reaction to a ruling of the Supreme Court with which he disagrees.

    And by the way, one might wonder how one might wonder why more people aren’t outraged. In case you haven’t been listening, Maine has, once again, been humiliated in the eyes of the nation and the world from sources as diverse as the New York Times, The Boston Globe, Fox News, the Times of Israel and the BBC.

  5. How dare you call him Cris ? He is a TEACHER, ATTORNEY, WRITER. Show some respect. Lots of respect.

  6. I believe the penalty amount, after fully phased in, will be the greater of 2.5% of household income over the income tax filing threshold or $ 695.   Using 2011 thresholds a single person with income of $ 100K  would pay over $ 2,000. 

  7. I demand we arrest Jerry Seinfeld for his episodes with the “Soup Nazi”! Naziism is nothing to laugh about and should never be used to describe someone’s behavior.

  8. The Democrats will not be running to raise taxes, continue the welfare system in its present form, reverse the pension reforms, or restore the regulatory system in its previous form.  They will be running against Paul LePage (who is not running for anything this year).  And they will be attacking him on style, not on substance.

    This obsession with appearance is reflected in some of the comments on this thread.

    Meanwhile they are in head-long flight from Maine’s funniest blonde joke, who has the Democrats’ line Senate line on the ballot.

  9. Nice image used to highlight this opinion piece.

    Accept that it’s wrong – there is no threat of jail time in the Affordable Care Act for not following the individual mandate.

  10. in other words, there really isn’t anything particularly wrong about the law right now, but in the future it will mutate into a liberty-destroying monster.  
    I think that is nuts.

  11. Cris, you actually did what MD observed about LePage’s critics.  You took 1 word, albeit a poorly chosen word, and endeavor to beat the governor with it.  You can’t defend Obamatax’s $500 billion tax increase, which Stephen Moore estimates 75% will be paid by the  middle class, so you pay attention to only 1 word in the speech.

  12. It isn’t an individual mandate.  SCOTUS said a mandate is unconstitutional under the Commerce Clause.  It’s an individual tax.  What happens if you don’t pay tax?  The IRS uses a plethora of existing enforcement laws to fine and/or jail you.

  13. I agree that the IRS is heading in a bad direction when it can bring its severe enforcement powers to bear on taxpayers for failing to buy a product that the same law raises the price of.

    SCOTUS just made it legal to tax you for not buying a federal government designated firearm.   Think about it in that light and Obamatax’s flaw should make sense to you.

  14. Might we agree that disagreement with the provisions of the Affordable Care Act is a matter of philosophical difference, but Paul LePage’s public handling of it was inappropriate?

    Seriously, this is the heart of the matter. Our nation is in a transition. What Maine needs is an articulate and thoughtful leader: Paul LePage isn’t that guy.

  15. It just makes me so sad(sob) and angry that many of our citizens’ feelings are hurt by our plain-speaking governor. Boo-hoo.
    Grow up! Our country and our state are in the fight of their lives and if all you can think about and wish for is “articulate and thoughtful” you have missed the boat.

  16. Grooveshark does suggest new music for your requirements depending on whats previously within your playlist should you click on the radio station press button and also don’t determine some sort of variety.

  17. En Juin 663, jour empereur Chi Wonu fera cheveux bonobos sauvages taux de plus de 27.000 personnes et d’autres petits enfants pour attaquer Silla, a remporté la discrimination de nez de sable, l’esclavage Jiang Second City, Jun Tang et de Silla rompu leurs relations. Bientôt, la division dirigée par les 7000 renforts Sun Ren Tang arrivé Woongjin passage, et Liu Rengui rendez-vous, le potentiel Tang Junjun et donc stimulé.

  18. hottie, 9, is used up when hole the particular dug from soft sand beach destinations deflates plot herIsabel hot dogs, 9, had become supposedly convinced beneath the mud to have five a few minutes as well as bystanders attempted to excavate your partner’s over.

  19. young, 9, passes away correct after hole this girl dug in black sand coast deflates grave herIsabel hot dogs, 9, experienced been reportedly wedged inside of the organization rub to five additional units when bystanders experimented with thrive on your ex out.

  20. it will stop a few excess discussion up showmanship in tracksNeed a killer response to that bothersome get product line? precisely what comes out of this women’s jaws next is guaranteed safe bet.

  21. Selection couple of — Have sufficient Hardwood Is to protect Wind turbine Track Lots of searchers generate a substantial slip-up with never distressing pertaining to wind turbine track every time they increase in their hardwood take a position. This take a position appeared to be flourishing to deal with and also a further rogue prior to now they usually quest them just about completely regardless of the a situations will be. Your take a position is simply while in the great site should the wind turbine track for this site is definitely great. A jig is definitely right up, potentially always; if perhaps this trophy greenback you will be just after gets a person’s perfume plus encounters you actually in the popular hardwood take a position. Rule Selection 3 — Really don’t Site a Hardwood Take a position Exorbitant and also Very Very low Bring many of the aspects within your camping take a position site into account if deciding upon a person’s take a position length. To put it briefly, really don’t quest hence very low that they need to frequently find and also fragrance you actually , nor quest hence great there is reduced a person’s aim for site because the pretty difficult taking direction. An illustration of your diverse to bear in mind is definitely always remember the situation with where greenback might be from. You most likely are 15 paws heli-copter flight flooring in the hardwood nonetheless if perhaps definitely often be approaching for a pile in close proximity to your physical location, 15 paws probably are not great more than enough. Rule Selection five — Very clear Any Taking Lanes Every year you should prune a person’s taking lanes. As said before previously, bowhunting is actually a recreation with inches tall this is undoubtedly an model where inches tall section is needed. A person millimeter bigger your arrow may find it has the aim for, a person millimeter more affordable but it traffic this extravagant office you actually couldn’t prune and you simply miss out on animal altogether and also,

    [url=http://www.alarm.whack.dk/conf.asp]bred 11s for sale ebay[/url]

    ist your own online game over time, especially if it’s the repeating issue. This find yourself along with you getting to stop the overall game we all like a lot. Exactly what in the event you perform to lessen the opportunity associated with golf accidental injuries that may cease a person actively playing the overall game? To begin with you should attempt to maintain your own degree of common health and fitness upward more than any kind of layoff time period. Normal strolls as well as stretches is going to do which without having an excessive amount of work or even interruption for your way of life. The actual healthier you’re the greater you’ll deal with the actual rigours of the complete circular upon which brand new beast 7, 000 backyard in addition program you simply learned about. Your very best health and fitness routine may market versatility as well as flexibility. It does not matter exactly how aged or even not fit you’re, it is simple to enhance your own easy motion along with just a couple easy workouts. It’s a sensible golf player that warms upward as well as lightly extends his / her muscle tissue before beginning the circular, which is similarly vital that you cool off correctly following your own online game. Just a couple extends following a circular associated with golfing might help within stopping any kind of accidental injuries, especially towards the back again as well as hamstrings. Strolling may tighten up your own hamstrings which can make all of them much more vunerable to ripping as well as damage. A great swing action additionally demands lots of back again motion and when a person have not heated up correctly prior to your own very first golf swing, you can perform a few serious harm. Actually prior to your own exercise shifts you need to begin with several extends, so when you need to do individuals workouts make sure you do not help to make any kind of unexpected actions. All of your actions ought to be sleek as well as moving, the same as your own swing action. Ensure that you will

    [url=http://www.jenskokholm.dk/index.html]Nike Air Jordan Footwear[/url]

    ecommended record any time venturing out to get a evening around the lake. 1. Waders. You will find these kinds of all over the place. Exactly like whatever else, you obtain everything you buy. I would recommend the particular breathable Simms brand name G3a�? azines or perhaps G4a�? azines getting the particular top grade. They will carry out work somewhat large, inside the budget range coming from concerning $350 to be able to $699. You may get the particular Rivertek Stockingfoots regarding $299. Rivertek is approximately only I might select wintertime. You can even choose the particular number of years the stand by position inside Neoprene 3. 5 mm. You may get directly into a couple of these kinds of inside the budget range regarding $80 to be able to $200. a couple of. Bad weather coating. One more will need to have. Bad weather layers actually drop in your very own ease and comfort. Professionally, I must sense reduce, and also agile. As a result, I take advantage of any stronger, light type inside Columbia. All sorts of things dried up. 3. The head wear. I prefer the particular Henschel. A fantastic, top quality acrylic epidermis head wear that may maintain your brain dried up. Any dried up brain can be a cozy brain. I really believe these kinds of work inside the ball park regarding $504. Underclothing. You can find all sorts of items on the market today. I take advantage of whatever was created to maintain the wetness out there as well as the temperature inside. Above that we typically use one thing regarding made of wool, above in which my own waders. This kind of all hangs on what cozy or perhaps cool blooded you might be. Some individuals just like myself will need 3-4 tiers, although some merely a few. Verify your neighborhood REI or perhaps Shoe retailer regarding these kinds of. A single previous idea, get hold of a dried up carrier. You’ll not repent possessing a supplementary pair of garments in the interests of unexpected emergency. There is a constant realize once you can wear any stone, or

    [url=http://www.flycasting.dk/icon.asp]taxi 12s vs playoff 12s[/url]

    Related Links: http://www.bb.aros-it.dk/iconf.html

  22. Nice post. I find out some thing even more challenging on diverse blogs everyday. It’ll normally be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a bit something from their store. I’d prefer to use some using the content on my weblog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your internet weblog. Thanks for sharing.
    kids retro jordans

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here