Are Maine’s cash welfare recipients gambling with taxpayer money?
According to The Maine Wire’s investigation into the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program, the answer is, yes!
The Maine Wire obtained three years’ worth of TANF transaction data from the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) pursuant to a Freedom of Access Act request. Analysis of that data shows Maine Electronic Benefit Transfer (EBT) cards have been used to access welfare cash in Las Vegas and at multiple gambling facilities in New Hampshire.
[RELATED: Welfare cash spent at Funtown Splashtown, Aquaboggan…]
At Seacoast Bingo LLC in Somersworth, N.H., Maine EBT card users have accessed an ATM 75 times, extracting nearly $4,500 in gambling dough. In 2013 alone, Maine taxpayers have covered $1,660 in bets at the bingo table.
At The Poker Room, located in Hampton Falls, N.H., $140 in welfare cash has been gambled away.
Additional transactions at the Hampton Beach Casino in Hampton, N.H. show $60 taken from an ATM on June 20, 2013.
Further analysis of DHHS records suggests that some welfare recipients are spending their cash welfare allotment on lottery scratch tickets. Though the state classifies such transactions as improper, and many store owners refuse to process such transactions, EBT cards can technically be used to buy scratchers.
[RELATED: Robinson talks welfare abuse with Howie Carr…]
To see whether welfare cash has been spent on scratch tickets, one must simply look at the number of round-dollar transactions, such as $1.00, $2.00, and $5.00, relative to non-round dollar transactions, such as $1.99, $2.57, and $5.15. Round-dollar transactions, due to the pricing of lottery tickets, could potential be purchases of lottery tickets.
[RELATED: Maine welfare cash spent in all 50 states, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands…]
If round dollar and non-round dollar transactions occur at the same frequency, then the data does not suggest lottery ticket purchases. However, if round-dollar transactions are more common than non-round dollar transactions, the data does suggest lottery ticket purchases.
So, according to the data, what occurs more often: $1.99 purchases not likely to include lottery tickets, or a high volume of $3.00, $5.00, etc., round transactions suggestive of lottery ticket purchases?
According to the above graph, round dollar transactions occur at a significantly higher rate than non-round dollar transactions, suggesting EBT cards have in fact been used to purchase lottery tickets. (Note: This graph does not include $10.00 or $20.00 amounts. Although transactions at these values may reflect scratch ticket purchases, they also equal common bank-related transactions that cannot possibly involve lottery tickets.)
Ultimately, it’s impossible to say with certainty that the pattern demonstrated above shows that a large volume of welfare cash has been spent on lottery tickets. But now that the data is available online (here), taxpayers can judge for themselves.
All of these gambling-related transactions include only instances where a welfare recipient swiped their EBT card at a gambling facility or for a transaction that could involve lottery tickets. This information does not include instances where a welfare recipient withdrew cash from an ATM and subsequently engaged in taxpayer-funded gambling activities at one of Maine’s casinos. Just as it is possible that an EBT cardholder withdraw cash at the bingo hall and later bought diapers, it is possible that welfare cash withdrawn at a Walmart was later used for gambling.
The Maine Wire’s exclusive investigation into TANF abuse also uncovered Maine welfare cash has been spent in all 50 states, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. Cash welfare has also been accessed at numerous liquor stores, bars, cigarette shops, strip clubs and amusement parks.
Steve Robinson
Editor, Maine Wire
[email protected]
What are the options for eliminating the fraud?
For each option will the cost of eliminating the fraud result in a net savings?
Does the cost of eliminating fraud include the time spent by government officials?
What work does not get done by government officials working on the fraud issue and what is that cost?
Will the correction of the fraud issue affect those not fraudulent in their use of the EBT? Has this been factored into the net savings?
I do not deny there is fraud; where there is money there is greed – we see that every day in the private sector and in the public sector. However, the governor and the MaineWire have not clearly defined fraud as evidenced by a number of comments to this article. Without clear definition of what is fraud in this case and with that its cost, evaluation of corrective measures cannot begin.
Is the timing of this report part of the governor’s campaign strategy? Politics before people? Will he drag this along until November in order to show how he is addressing Maine’s financial challenges? I would prefer he demonstrate how he will create jobs without destroying the environment.
Is this another avenue to encourage drug-testing of all welfare recipients? If so will that cost be included in the options for addressing fraud? What have been the results of drug testing in other states, cost versus benefit? I will gladly support any type of drug testing on citizens providing it is also performed on all public sector employees. They are paid from the same pool of taxpayer money as the EBT.
The headline, the picture, the over-arching generalities, and cherry-picked data points of this article are Sensationalism 101. They are intended to get the emotional blood flowing, but not the brain. This is an insult to the intellect of all Mainers.
FYI…The Hampton Beach Casino Ballroom is not a casino, it’s an event center…
in portland maine at a hanafords my best friend was behind an immagrent that was buying liquour with an ebt card,when he complained was told that the rules were different for them.
just because they use the card at a smoke shop does not mean they bought cigarettes,some poor people live by them and the atm is close to use
these cards are all numbered just like a credit card,would like to see the names of the users.
Thanks for info! Its great
I can totally relate to your situation, Charlotte. It can be tough to get the timing right, especially with the randomness of the game. The AI-powered tool on https://aviatorpredictor.in/ works by analyzing historical game data, such as how long planes have stayed in the air in previous rounds and the patterns they tend to follow. The AI then uses this information to predict the likelihood of a crash happening within a certain timeframe. It helps you make more informed decisions by showing you when the odds are better for cashing out. It’s not a magical solution, but it certainly improves your chances of playing strategically rather than just relying on gut feelings.