The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • NH Trans Man Who Allegedly Murdered Wife Had Previously Hosted “Ask a Trans Woman Anything”
  • A Tale Of Two Maine Canneries: Contrasting Redevelopment Efforts In Prospect Harbor, Eastport
  • NH Man Arrested for Posing as Teenager Online to Elicit Sexually Explicit Material from Minor
  • Mount Desert Island Hospital Disciplines Nurses Who Protested the Closure of Its Maternity Ward
  • Alabama Man Arrested, Facing Federal Charges for Alleged Threats Against Bangor International Airport
  • Indian National Admits Role in Staged Armed Robberies for Visa Fraud Scheme in Boston
  • Maine CD2 Front-Runner Paul LePage Joins the Robinson Report [VIDEO]
  • By the Seat of Her Pants, Mills Signs Slew of Orders to Cover Another Set of Massive Payroll Shortfalls
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Saturday, May 24
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
The Maine Wire
Home » News » News » Home sharing should never be a crime in Maine
News

Home sharing should never be a crime in Maine

Jacob PosikBy Jacob PosikFebruary 20, 2019Updated:March 1, 2019No Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

Maine’s Joint Standing Committee on State and Local Government today is holding a public hearing on LD 209, a bill that would prohibit municipalities from banning short-term rentals within their communities.

Limiting or restricting the use of short-term rentals, unless for public health and safety concerns, is unnecessary. This kind of regulation suppresses the entrepreneurial spirit of individuals who want to generate income by sharing their property. Prohibitions on short-term rentals unfairly restrict individuals and families who share their homes responsibly, and Maine should pursue statewide protections for those who do.

Municipal bans on short-term rentals chip away at the private property rights of individuals. As long as someone is using their property in a safe and responsible manner, government should not dictate what individuals can or cannot do with it. Enacting prohibitions on short-term rentals and regulating them outside of the scope of health and safety is a slippery slope that results in the diminishment of private property rights.

To be clear, the bill does not prevent communities from reasonably regulating short-term rentals; it simply states that municipalities cannot prohibit their operation. LD 209 does not undermine local authority and control. Cities and towns can still regulate noise and crime. But for many municipalities, existing rules already do this by targeting specific nuisance behaviors, instead of prohibiting people from using their own property in responsible ways. As Christina Sandefur, executive vice president of the Goldwater Institute wrote in a 2017 op-ed, “cities do not forbid all backyard barbeques just because some might get noisy – they enforce reasonable restrictions on noise, while respecting people’s rights to use their property.”

And while municipal governments are free to regulate noise and nuisance behaviors, they should keep in mind that home sharing sites and companies are cooperating with local governments and have developed mechanisms for neighbors of short-term rental properties to report annoyances through platform-specific tools.

For example, if a complaint is recorded with Airbnb, they reach out to the host so the issue can be addressed. If the host ignores complaints, they can be banned from using Airbnb as a platform for renting out their property. The private sector has and is continuing to create solutions to these problems without hindering entrepreneurship, and without the directive from government.

When Arizona passed protections for short-term rental properties, individuals were free to use their homes to fulfill their entrepreneurial dreams. Glenn Odegard bought an old, vacant, and structurally unsound house in Jerome, Arizona, and with his skills in carpentry, he restored the house to create a historical experience for folks who wanted to visit.

In 2015, Jerome prohibited short-term vacation rentals, which would have stopped Mr. Odegard from fulfilling his dream. Homeowners who did not comply with the rules were subject to $300 in fines and 90 days in jail for each day they disobeyed the town’s ordinance and rented their home to short-term tenants. Through Arizona’s intervention, a state law was passed to stop prohibitions on short-term rentals, encouraging folks like Mr. Odegard to pursue their aspirations.

Some Mainers have already been subjected to prohibitions on short-term rentals through ordinances that use zoning and building classifications to ban the operation of certain types of short-term rentals in specific areas of a city.

Instead of pursuing outright bans that create more problems than they solve, Maine should pass LD 209 to continue allowing municipalities to regulate in ways that protect public health and safety while protecting the property rights of homeowners who want to use their property in a responsible manner.

Airbnb Commentary Featured homesharing Opinion private property private property rights sharing economy short-term rental vacationland
Previous ArticleMaine should end tax increases at the ballot box
Next Article Medicaid expansion will cost our state dearly
Jacob Posik

Jacob Posik, of Turner, is the director of legislative affairs at Maine Policy Institute. He formerly served as policy analyst and communications director at Maine Policy, as well as editor of the Maine Wire. Posik can be reached at jposik@mainepolicy.org.

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

NH Trans Man Who Allegedly Murdered Wife Had Previously Hosted “Ask a Trans Woman Anything”

May 23, 2025

A Tale Of Two Maine Canneries: Contrasting Redevelopment Efforts In Prospect Harbor, Eastport

May 23, 2025

NH Man Arrested for Posing as Teenager Online to Elicit Sexually Explicit Material from Minor

May 23, 2025

Leave A Reply

Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

NH Trans Man Who Allegedly Murdered Wife Had Previously Hosted “Ask a Trans Woman Anything”

May 23, 2025

A Tale Of Two Maine Canneries: Contrasting Redevelopment Efforts In Prospect Harbor, Eastport

May 23, 2025

NH Man Arrested for Posing as Teenager Online to Elicit Sexually Explicit Material from Minor

May 23, 2025

Mount Desert Island Hospital Disciplines Nurses Who Protested the Closure of Its Maternity Ward

May 23, 2025

Alabama Man Arrested, Facing Federal Charges for Alleged Threats Against Bangor International Airport

May 23, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.