The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • USDA Shuts Down U.S. Mexico Livestock Trade to Contain Deadly Flesh-Eating Parasite Spreading in Mexico That Can Devastate Herds and Infest Humans
  • Maine’s “Success” Battling Overdoses Lost In The (Chinese) Weeds
  • Maine Supreme Court Upholds Shenna Bellows’ Wording of Voter ID Referendum Question
  • Circuit Court Voids FTC’s Rules Making It Easier to Cancel Subscriptions, But Mainers Will Still Reap the Benefits Under New, Bipartisan Law
  • Jared Golden Sponsors Bill Increasing Penalties for Violence Against Law Enforcement as Attacks Spike
  • Massachusetts Republican Party Credits The Maine Wire for Triad Weed Bust in Their State
  • Pro-Mamdani PAC Took Donation From Islamist Cleric Who Vouched For Terror Plot Mastermind
  • Kids Behaving Badly: Six Juveniles Charged in Connection to Burglaries, Vandalism in Bingham
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Saturday, July 12
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
    • Contact
  • Investigations
    • Data
  • Donate
The Maine Wire
Home » News » News » Lawsuit Seeks to Invalidate EMS Vaccine Mandate
News

Lawsuit Seeks to Invalidate EMS Vaccine Mandate

Steve RobinsonBy Steve RobinsonMarch 29, 2023Updated:March 29, 2023No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

A legal challenge filed on behalf of Mainers who lost their jobs as a result of a COVID-19 vaccine mandate could determine whether the Maine Emergency Medical Services (Maine EMS) had the authority to implement such a mandate.

Health Choice Maine (HCM), a non-profit group that advocates for medical freedom, is the driving force behind the decision to challenge the mandate. The case has 18 named plaintiffs, as well as classes of John and Jane Does.

“The question we posed to the court is whether the agency had the authority to do this,” said Terry Mitrenga, the attorney representing HCM.

“The crux of our case is that this was done by an agency aside from DHHS,” she said. “All of the other mandates have been done by DHHS.”

At this point, the Maine Attorney General’s Office has filed a series of procedural motions that have little to do with the substance of HCM’s argument against the mandate. But those procedural complaints could have the effect of running out the clock on the plaintiffs, so to speak.

“The state always in every type of case, whether they’re defending an agency or an individual, they always have the upper hand because they have substantial resources,” she said.

Assistant Attorney General Sarah E. Coleman is representing the state.

Resistance to the EMS mandate has exacerbated a serious shortage of Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) in the state.

Corey Bonnevie, a 20-year veteran paramedic who has worked in western Maine for 15 years, said even before the mandate caused the EMT ranks to shrink, he had often found himself as the only ambulance servicing an area 1,500 square miles or more.

“There was a call that came in, and I was in Rangeley. Chest pain in Livermore Falls,” said Bonnevie.

“That’s a high level call. This is chest pain. You need to get there. When it comes to a heart attack or any heart problem, time is everything. On a good day, and really hauling, that’s an hour and a half, bare minimum, to get to someone who has dialed 9-1-1,” he said.

“This happened multiple times,” he said. “It wasn’t just me.”

All of that was before the mandate.

Bonnevie said he had a religious exemption for the flu vaccine and a medical exemption. A medical doctor provided him with the exemption after he had a serious adverse reaction to a flu immunization. But the company he worked for refused to accept his pre-existing medical and religious exemptions, he said.

So after 20 years serving as a first responder, he ended up jobless in the middle of the pandemic.

He lost his career, his wife, his home — even his band and his dog.

“Everything I had was essentially destroyed,” he said. “I was essentially homeless.”

Bonnevie isn’t the only one who thinks Maine’s emergency services are in crisis.

In January, Maine EMS released a blue ribbon commission report that came to a similar conclusion.

“EMS services in Maine are at the edge of a cliff, or over it, and changes must occur to ensure that when someone calls with a medical emergency, EMS services are able and ready to assist,” the report said.

The words “vaccine” and “mandate” do not appear in the report.

The plaintiffs on HCM’s case are seeking financial damages, and many say they’ve endured extreme economic hardship as the result of the mandate.

But the big outcome HCM wants is for towns to rehire emergency medical professionals who were fired, quit in response to the mandate, or otherwise lost their employment because of the mandate.

If HCM wins the case, the real winners just might be rural Mainers who would like to know that someday if they need to dial 9-1-1, help won’t be hours away.

Tiffany Kreck, HCM’s co-founder and director, joined WVOM’s George Hale and Ric Tyler radio show this morning to talk about the case.

Previous ArticleMaine City Council Wants to Ban Gas-Powered Lawn Mowers
Next Article High Electricity, Fiber Costs Shutter Old Town Mill
Steve Robinson
  • Twitter

Steve Robinson is the Editor-in-Chief of The Maine Wire. ‪He can be reached by email at Robinson@TheMaineWire.com.

Subscribe to Substack

Related Posts

USDA Shuts Down U.S. Mexico Livestock Trade to Contain Deadly Flesh-Eating Parasite Spreading in Mexico That Can Devastate Herds and Infest Humans

July 12, 2025

Maine’s “Success” Battling Overdoses Lost In The (Chinese) Weeds

July 12, 2025

Maine Supreme Court Upholds Shenna Bellows’ Wording of Voter ID Referendum Question

July 11, 2025

Leave A Reply

Subscribe to Substack
Recent News

USDA Shuts Down U.S. Mexico Livestock Trade to Contain Deadly Flesh-Eating Parasite Spreading in Mexico That Can Devastate Herds and Infest Humans

July 12, 2025

Maine Supreme Court Upholds Shenna Bellows’ Wording of Voter ID Referendum Question

July 11, 2025

Circuit Court Voids FTC’s Rules Making It Easier to Cancel Subscriptions, But Mainers Will Still Reap the Benefits Under New, Bipartisan Law

July 11, 2025

Jared Golden Sponsors Bill Increasing Penalties for Violence Against Law Enforcement as Attacks Spike

July 11, 2025

Massachusetts Republican Party Credits The Maine Wire for Triad Weed Bust in Their State

July 11, 2025
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.