The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
  • Support the Maine Wire
  • Store
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Supreme Court Strikes Down Louisiana Congressional Map As An “Unconstitutional Racial Gerrymander”
  • Mayor Of York County’s Largest City Rejects College Presidentโ€™s Plea For Marriage Counselor
  • Maine’s Minimum Salary for Teachers Raised to $50,000 Annually by Fall 2029 Under New Supplemental Budget
  • Bellows Sets Hearing Date for Challenge to Ballot Initiative Barring Males from Girls’ Sports and Spaces
  • Protest at Massachusetts ICE Facility Leads to Arrests of Eight Mainers
  • California Tech Company Facing Federal Lawsuit for Hiring Foreigners While Discriminating Against U.S. Workers
  • Maine Lawmakers Uphold Mills’ Surprise Veto of AI Datacenter Moratorium
  • New England Patriots Scouting Around For Possible Replacement Of Embattled Head Coach Mike Vrabel
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Thursday, April 30
  • News
  • Commentary
  • The Blog
  • About
  • Support the Maine Wire
  • Store
The Maine Wire
Home ยป News ยป Media ยป Bates College Prof Exposes “White Rural Rage” Authors as “Egregious” Frauds
Media

Bates College Prof Exposes “White Rural Rage” Authors as “Egregious” Frauds

The shockingly bad attempt at popular sociology was first exposed by Bates College professor Tyler Austin Harper via a series of X posts and a lengthy article in The Atlantic.
Steve RobinsonBy Steve RobinsonApril 5, 2024Updated:April 8, 20245 Comments1 Min Read2K Views
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

When Tom Schaller and Paul Waldman released their new book, “White Rural Rage: The Threat to American Democracy,” the publication was heralded by the usual suspects as MSNBC and CNN as the definitive and timely magnum opus confirming, once and for all, that redneck Trump voters living in the willywacks are a genuine threat to America, democracy, and pretty much everything.

There’s only one problem: the entire book is fraudulent, based on sloppy research, and the authors demonstrated a pattern of ignoring or misconstruing the opinions of the experts they consulted.

The shockingly bad attempt at popular sociology was first exposed by Bates College professor Tyler Austin Harper via a series of X posts and a lengthy article in The Atlantic.

The Atlantic article is paywalled, but Harper posted an illuminating X thread showing the problems, errors, and ethical lapses that contributed to Schaller and Waldman’s hilarious inaccurate and tortured book, which I’ll post below.

โ€œAs serious scholarship has shown, the right-wing rage we need to worry about is not coming from deep-red rural areas,โ€ @Tyler_A_Harper writes. โ€œIt is coming from cities and suburbs.โ€ https://t.co/TNMrK5PJp2

— The Atlantic (@TheAtlantic) April 5, 2024

I wrote about the book White Rural Rage and the scapegoating of rural people.

I talked to over 20 experts in the field of rural studies and found a pattern of errors, distortions, and misleading uses of scholarship in Schaller and Waldmanโ€™s book. Itโ€™s egregious.

Buckle up. ๐Ÿงต https://t.co/4NOSKcBdl5

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

If youโ€™re not familiar with the book โ€” which spent weeks on the NYT bestseller list โ€” White Rural Rage claims that white rural Americans are a โ€œthreat to democracy,โ€ and rural America is a hotbed of racism, xenophobia, potential violence, homophobia, and general dirt-baggery. 2/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

Anyone who follows me knows that I think White Rural Rage is beyond the pale. Iโ€™ve made no effort to hide my distaste for Schaller and Waldmanโ€™s thesis, which is both shopworn and offensive. But I had assumed that their research was at least on solid footing. 3/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

I contacted over 20 scholars in the fieldโ€”most of them cited in White Rural Rageโ€”to ask if they thought these three reviews and the accusations against Schaller and Waldman were fair, and what they thought of the book.

A majority were critical. Not one defended the book. 5/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

I found a host of problems.

There are two kinds of errors Schaller & Waldman make over and over:

1. Describing places as โ€œruralโ€ that are NOT rural, but urban/metro.

2. Repeatedly distorting studies to fit their claims about rurality and the threat of political violence. 7/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

Another instance: they spotlight several violent extremists as part of an effort to frame rural places as hotbeds of potential political violence. Guess what? The examples they cite are bad apples from METRO areas (RUCA 1 or 2) that the authors falsely imply are โ€œrural.โ€ 9/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

The article says the opposite: most political violence occurs in swing district SUBURBS. They cite another study they say shows rural people are more likely to favor violence over democratic deliberation. That article NEVER MENTIONS either violence or democratic deliberation. 11/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

The most brazen issue in White Rural Rage is Schaller and Waldmanโ€™s use of a study by UChicagoโ€™s Robert Pape as evidence that rural people are prone to โ€œinsurrectionist tendencies.โ€ The studyโ€™s bold-lettered, key finding is that URBAN Trump supporters are the biggest threat. 13/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

When I contacted Papeโ€”who directs the Chicago center that ran the study and issued the aforementioned reportโ€”he was unsparing in his criticism of Schaller and Waldmanโ€™s use of his work, as well as White Rural Rage. But he emphasized: academic negligence isnโ€™t the real story. 15/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

Instead of confronting the facts that didnโ€™t fit their tidy story about scary hillbillies, Schaller and Waldman wrote an error-laden book that misuses and misreads studies in the service of their agenda. And they demonized disadvantaged and disproportionately poor Americans. 17/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

The authorsโ€™ incuriosity about WHY rural Americans feel so aggrievedโ€”paying occasional lip service to deindustrialization, gesturing vaguely at โ€œlate capitalismโ€ only to lead with psychologizing rather than material analysisโ€”prevented them from writing a book worth reading. 19/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

I contacted ten of the experts thanked in the acknowledgmentsโ€”figuring theyโ€™d be the most likely to praise the book and offer a balanced viewโ€”but I was shocked to hear that almost all of them had only exchanged a few emails with the authors and were surprised to be thanked. 21/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

To get this story right, I spent a month talking to scholars in rural studies. I found a warm and open-minded scholarly community that was not interested in demonizing rural folks or giving them a free pass, but understanding rural politics with compassion and intelligence. 23/

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

Iโ€™d like to thank the many scholars who provided input, assistance, and/or expertise over the last month as I waded through too many studies to count and asked far too many questions. They include (but are not limited to): @ZoeNemerever, @klunztrujillo, @camwimpy, @keithdorejelโ€ฆ

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

If you would like to read the full Chicago Project on Security and Threats report, lead by @ProfessorPape, that I mention in tweet #14, you can find it at the link below. It provides great info on the far-right suburban and urban antidemocratic threat.https://t.co/cjpDeu9Fgc

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024

If you would like to read the CPOST report on the January 6th insurrection (not cited in White Rural Rage) that I include a screenshot of in tweet #16, you can find that at the link below. It makes for a very illuminating read. https://t.co/AUpySVKqUi

— Tyler Austin Harper (@Tyler_A_Harper) April 4, 2024
Previous ArticleSurge in Government Jobs, Part-time Gigs Boosts March Job Numbers: BLS
Next Article Maine Dems Plow Ahead With Hearing on “Red Flag” Bill Despite 200k+ Mainers Without Power
Steve Robinson
  • Twitter

Steve Robinson is the Editor-in-Chief of The Maine Wire. โ€ชHe can be reached by email at [email protected].

Latest News

Supreme Court Strikes Down Louisiana Congressional Map As An “Unconstitutional Racial Gerrymander”

April 29, 2026

Maine’s Minimum Salary for Teachers Raised to $50,000 Annually by Fall 2029 Under New Supplemental Budget

April 29, 2026

Bellows Sets Hearing Date for Challenge to Ballot Initiative Barring Males from Girls’ Sports and Spaces

April 29, 2026
0 0 votes
Article Rating
5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Rev Kev
Rev Kev
2 years ago

The protective maternal archetype popular on the suburban Left is bringing the violence, not white male rural rage.

1
ME Infidel
ME Infidel
2 years ago

The Legacy Media is dead and has been for a long time. They just donโ€™t realize it yet.

1
Chris
Chris
2 years ago

Imagine that! Couple of leftist frauds accusing whitey of all the leftist tropes. You gun totin, MAGA, tobacco chewin, beer drinkin, pickup drivin, flag wavin, citizens are the real problem in America. Well I’ll be!

0
roy
roy
2 years ago

And F them jooze in particular

0
FastNeat
FastNeat
2 years ago

These two should be barred from eating any food produced in by “white rage” farmers in rural America.

0
Recent News

Supreme Court Strikes Down Louisiana Congressional Map As An “Unconstitutional Racial Gerrymander”

April 29, 2026

Maine’s Minimum Salary for Teachers Raised to $50,000 Annually by Fall 2029 Under New Supplemental Budget

April 29, 2026

Bellows Sets Hearing Date for Challenge to Ballot Initiative Barring Males from Girls’ Sports and Spaces

April 29, 2026

Protest at Massachusetts ICE Facility Leads to Arrests of Eight Mainers

April 29, 2026

California Tech Company Facing Federal Lawsuit for Hiring Foreigners While Discriminating Against U.S. Workers

April 29, 2026
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

wpDiscuz