Sussman Press Herald Passes on Another GOP Op-Ed


Last Sunday, the Donald Sussman/Chellie Pingree owned Press Herald ran an editorial titled “Republicans fail to honor their word.” The piece was about the recent decision by the majority of Maine’s legislature not to re-convene early to attempt an override of Governor LePage’s recent line-item veto of the budget bill.

The Press Herald said that, “Republican lawmakers decided in a secret poll not to support the budget compromise they had publicly backed just a few days earlier.”

An earlier version of the story called out the Senate Republicans for their lack of transparency, although the Senate Republicans had released the poll showing how each Senator had voted four days earlier.

At 3am yesterday, the PPH offered a correction on their website version of the op-ed, saying they “mischaracterized Republican senators’ transparency in letting stand Gov. LePage’s line-item vetoes.”

The Press Herald editorial ran four days after Senate Republicans say they had sent an op-ed from Senators Mike Thibodeau and Ron Collins, that explained their reasons for voting Nay to go back into session ahead of schedule to address the line-item veto. Senate Republicans assert that the PPH had agreed to run it on Friday the 20th, but it did not appear.

The PPH editorial, however, mistake included, did run on Sunday the 22nd and the Senate Republicans decided to withdraw their submission of their own op-ed. In a press release they noted that, “our piece has still not run and we are dismayed by the total lack of objectivity on the part of the newspaper [PPH]. Why can’t readers be presented with competing opinions and make up their own minds?”

Below, in it’s entirety, is the Senate Republican op-ed that the Press Herald passed on:


Legislative Republicans will address the general assistance shortfall in a responsible manner that protects taxpayers from unnecessary costs

By Senator Mike Thibodeau and Senator Ron Collins

Just last week, Governor LePage utilized a previously unused provision in Maine law: the line item veto. Passed during the King administration and supported by voters in a statewide referendum, the line-item veto can be used by Governors to object to portions of a budget without vetoing the entire document.

The two items Governor LePage chose to veto were a portion of the additional funds needed to cover a projected shortfall in the FY 2013 General Assistance allocation, and $3 million in “disproportionate share” funding to hospitals and psychiatric facilities in order to offset losses in federal funding. If the Legislature were meeting, we would take up a Governor’s veto within the prescribed time limit of five days. However, the Legislature is adjourned until May 15th, when we will return to finalize work on the FY 2013 supplemental budget.

Given the fact that the Legislature will be returning next month, legislators had to decide if it made sense to reconvene again within five days solely to deal with the line-item veto.

Maine’s Constitution – specifically Article IV, Part Third, Section 1 – provides that the Legislature may convene on the call of the President of the Senate and Speaker of the House, with consent of the majority of the members of the Legislature of each political party, all members of the Legislature having first been polled. Based upon this provision, and a letter from the House and Senate Democratic leaders, we conducted the poll of members of both parties required to grant consent to reconvening the Legislature. It failed when two-thirds of legislative Republicans declined to give consent to coming in this week.

As two Senators who voted not to reconvene, we are writing to highlight the reasoning behind our decision.  There is plenty of time to address the issues contained in the vetoes in a thoughtful, responsible manner that is both timely and respectful of the extra costs that would have been borne by taxpayers had we added yet another session day.

It is important to note that the supplemental budget we passed will fund the general assistance shortfall for the 2012 fiscal year that ends June 30th.  The line-item vetoes strike a portion of the projected additional appropriations needed to cover the general assistance shortfall in the fourth quarter of next year’s budget.

The vetoes leave in place several policy changes we made that will help us to address the issues going forward.  For example, a Department of Health and Human Services working group will proceed to review General Assistance Program rules and regulations and make recommendations to the Legislature no later than December 1, 2012. The focus of this stakeholder group is to improve the efficiency, effectiveness, uniformity, and financial accountability of the program. The budget passed by the Legislature also includes a reduction of the current reimbursement rate to service center municipalities from 90 percent to 85 percent and a nine month cap on housing, with some hardship exceptions. Even if the Legislature were to wait until January 2013 to act, it will have a full four months to address the projected shortfall.

The Legislature is now in recess until May 15th, pending revised revenue estimates due at the end of April and the work of the Appropriations Committee once those figures are available. When we return, we will act on the second FY 2013 supplemental budget, which addresses the estimated $85 million shortfall in the Department of Health and Human Services.

Reconvening the Legislature before May 15th would cost taxpayers an estimated $15,000 per day at a time when we are seeking ways to eliminate unnecessary costs. None of the items addressed in the line item vetoes will occur before we have the opportunity to address the issues.

As legislators, we have a responsibility to carefully weigh the issues and act in the best interests of sound policy and fiscal responsibility for the people of Maine. In short, convening the Legislature this week would have been an unnecessary exercise and expense. We will continue to work to address the general assistance shortfall and ensure that the program protects Maine’s most vulnerable citizens and is financially sustainable for taxpayers.


Senator Mike Thibodeau chairs the Energy, Utilities, and Technology Committee and is a member of the Agriculture, Conservation, and Forestry Committee. He represents Maine Senate District 23 which includes all of Waldo County.

Sen. Ron Collins chairs the Transportation Committee and is a member of the State and Local Government Committee. Collins represents Maine State Senate District 2 which includes the York County towns of Acton, Berwick, Cornish, Lebanon, Limerick, Newfield, North Berwick, Parsonsfield, Shapleigh, and Wells. Collins chairs the 125th Legislature’s Transportation Committee.



  1. There is no way that the Pingree People’s Herald is going to be fair, balanced and honest when it comes to reporting on anything thst has to do with Gov. LePage, the Republican majorities or anything of a conservative nature. The PPH was vilifying LePage even before he took office and it has only gotten worse since the ultra-left dynamic duo of Pingree-Sussman have taken over.

  2. Great! Senators using common sense. The Dems would love to see us Republicans running around yelling,”The sky is falling,the sky is falling!”

  3. Now that the news(?)paper is owned by the most generous donor to Maine’s Democratic Party  and consort of its most liberal congressmammal it makes no sense to even try maintaining the pretense of objectivity.

  4. The Portland Pravda has once again proven it’s worth, zero, and the Maine Wire has once again proven it’s worth, priceless.
    Great Article by 2 of Maine’s finest Senators. Ron Collins my fellow Chair of Transportation and Mike Thibodeau, Energy Chair. Well done Gentlemen. I too voted no waste, no way.

  5. This is a lousy excuse for a newspaper anyway. It never has amounted to much. Frankly, the BDN put’s the Portland paper to shame. I wonder how the subscription rate is doing. Why would anybody want that rag.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here