A group of medical professionals submitted a letter to Maine’s newspapers warning against Republican Gov. Paul LePage’s quarantine on nurse Kaci Hickox this week. Many of those medical professionals also happen to donors to Democratic candidate U.S. Rep. Michael Michaud.
“[Q]uarantining of all health care workers without symptoms upon their return from caring for Ebola patients in the affected countries may be well intended, but is not supported by the science or experience,” the letter states. “Ultimately we need to be guided by science and not emotion.”
Hickox’s refusal to follow the Center for Disease Control’s recommendations regarding individuals who have been exposed to the Ebola virus has drawn national attention.
Signatories of the letter who have donated to Michaud’s gubernatorial campaign include the following:
Judith Johnson donated $16.00 and $35.00 to Michaud in April.
Lani Graham donated $100.00 to Michaud in October.
Stephen Meister has donated $250.00 and $500.00 to Michaud.
Dervilla McCann has donated $500.00 to Michaud.
Dora Anne Mills has donated $500.00 to Michaud. (Note: Mills is the sister of hyper-partisan Maine Attorney General Janet Mills, who has often clashed with LePage and has sought to undermine his prosecution of welfare fraud.)
Peter Millard gave Michaud $100.00 in October.
Here is the text of the letter:
We are a group of Maine health professionals who are concerned about the epidemic of fear spreading in Maine and elsewhere about Ebola.
First, here are a few facts that we hope are helpful. We recognize that people are concerned about Ebola and there is a lot of conflicting information out there. However, it is reassuring that the World Health Organization (WHO) and many other public health agencies have 40 years of experience with Ebola. This is not a new virus. The current outbreak in three West African countries is behaving the same as others, but has spread because of extremely poor conditions as well as a lack of an adequate public health system and sufficient health workers to contain it.
The science and experience of many indicates that Ebola is only contagious once symptoms have occurred. Body fluids such as blood and vomit are most infectious in advanced stages of the disease. That is why the only two people to have contracted Ebola in the United States are two nurses who cared for a patient in Texas in the very end stages of the infection, and we understand the nurses were not fully protected.
Second, quarantining all health care workers without symptoms upon their return from caring for Ebola patients in the affected countries may be well intended, but it is not supported by the science or experience.
Even if a health care worker were unknowingly exposed to the Ebola virus while working in an affected area, 40 years of experience and biological evidence show they are not contagious before symptoms are present. This evidence also indicates that fever usually precedes the contagious stages, allowing time for people to identify themselves and be isolated before they can transmit it to others in the community.
Health care workers returning from affected areas of West Africa are instructed to monitor their temperature, and are isolated at the first signs of the disease. The case of a returning physician with Ebola in New York City is an example of this system working. Recent guidelines from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (U.S. CDC) have established recommendations for regular monitoring of health care workers and others who may have been exposed to Ebola to identify the earliest indications of illness.
Third, unnecessarily quarantining these returning health care workers can have a devastating impact on the efforts to stop Ebola at its source and ultimately here.
Most American health care providers working there are doing so selflessly as volunteers for several weeks. Very often they can only take a limited time off from work, and are unable to take an additional three weeks off for quarantine when they return. They and their families should also not have to face stigma and anger. Reports from aid organizations indicate that unnecessary quarantines and stigma are already negatively impacting the number of volunteer applicants to assist with the outbreak in parts of West Africa.
Centuries of experience with epidemics show that Ebola must be stopped at its source in order to prevent its spread elsewhere. In order to accomplish this, we need many thousands of health care workers to volunteer in these three affected countries in West Africa, and at this time we are far short of that. Unnecessary quarantines impede these efforts.
Everyone needs assurances with the facts. We also need assurances that returning workers will be monitored and advised, including active monitoring by state officials when warranted, according to the set guidance by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. And very importantly, by Americans helping to contain this outbreak at its source, all of us are safer.
Ultimately we need to be guided by science and not emotion. An epidemic of fear can be as dangerous as an epidemic with a virus.
We are joined by our colleagues representing the Maine Public Health Association (Tina Pettingill, MPH, Executive Director) as well as other distinguished Maine public health and health care leaders, including: Kathleen Gensheimer, MD, MPH (State Epidemiologist 1981 – 2009); Lisa Letourneau, MD, MPH; Dervilla McCann, MD; Steve Meister, MD, MHSA; Peter Millard, MD, PhD; Dora Anne Mills, MD, MPH (State Health Officer 1996 – 2011); Daniel Oppenheim, MD (co-chair of the Public Health Committee of the Maine Medical Association); Stephen Sears, MD, MPH, (State Epidemiologist 2011 – 2014 and infectious disease specialist); Rhonda Selvin, APRN (President of Maine Nurse Practitioner Association); Robert P. Smith, Jr., MD, MPH (Infectious Disease specialist); and Erik Steele, DO.
Sincerely,
Lisa Ryan, DO
President, Maine Medical Association
Lani Graham, MD, MPH
State Health Officer 1990-1996
5 Comments
Granting that all this is true, why was the plane sanitized after the other nurse had flown – symptom free – and all passengers and crew of the flights notified to undergo monitoring? As well as extensive cleaning of the apartment in Dallas? Seems that the CDC and WHO were both unprepared to deal with this well known virus. Hard to know what to believe and whom to trust, especially when statements and actions are contradictory.
Your Dirty Half-Dozen: Judith Johnson donated $51, Lani Graham donated $100, Stephen Meister donated $750, Dervilla McCann donated $500, Dora Anne Mills donated $500, and Peter Millard donated $100.
Wow. $2100 between them That’s about what any one top doctor would spend on a weekend with a spouse. Big time.
But you found NOTHING to carp about with the other signers? Nothing on:
Tina Pettingill, MPH, Executive Director.
Kathleen Gensheimer, MD, MPH (State Epidemiologist 1981 – 2009)
Lisa Letourneau, MD, MPH
Daniel Oppenheim, MD (co-chair of the Public Health Committee of the Maine Medical Association)
Stephen Sears, MD, MPH, (State Epidemiologist 2011 – 2014 and infectious disease specialist)
Rhonda Selvin, APRN (President of Maine Nurse Practitioner Association)
Robert P. Smith, Jr., MD, MPH (Infectious Disease specialist)
Erik Steele, DO.
Lisa Ryan, DO (President, Maine Medical Association)
?
If six was nine, you could say a majority of the signers contributed to Michaud.
As it is, you are left with your own diddling in the mud, writing bad things about your betters with twigs in your grubby little paws.
It’s interesting that Nobel Prize winning physician Dr. Bruce Beutler disagrees with our esteemed medical experts, saying we still don’t know enough about the possible ways this disease may be spread. He feels we need to err on the side of caution – not panic, just caution and common sense. I also think Steve Robinson possibly forgot to list all the LePage contributing “professionals” who signed on to this letter. There weren’t any? Well, now that’s interesting!
It is completely reckless on the part of these medical professionals to turn a blind eye on the CDC protocols to support a very unprofessional and arrogant Hickox.
Also, the fact that they are all supporters of Michaud is very telling.
No one can convince me that Democrat operatives didn’t prearrange this scenario.
Weird since Michaud is quoted as having the same view at LePage on this issue.