The Maine Wire
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • Podcasts
  • About
  • Contact
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending News
  • Two Men Arrested in Sanford Stabbing and Bike Theft Case
  • South Portland High School Locked Down This Morning After Suspicious Individual Spotted Near Entrance
  • Sen. Dianne Feinstein, Longest-Serving Female Senator, Dead At 90
  • Angus King and West Virginia Senator Partner to Designate September as ‘National Recovery Month’ Amid Rise in Overdoses
  • Senate Unanimously Approves Official Business-Appropriate Dress Code
  • ‘Enough is Enough’: Portland Business Owners Speak Out About Crime and Violence in City’s Homeless Encampments [VIDEO]
  • Low Approval Ratings for Congress and Biden Persist as Government Shutdown Looms: Gallup Poll
  • Sanford Man Stabbed Multiple Times After Having His Bike Stolen Near City’s Homeless Hot Spot
Facebook Twitter Instagram
The Maine Wire
Login
Saturday, September 30
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Maine Wire TV
  • Podcasts
  • About
  • Contact
The Maine Wire
Home » News » Misleading Arguments for Medicaid Expansion
Commentary

Misleading Arguments for Medicaid Expansion

Steve RobinsonBy Steve RobinsonNovember 23, 201310 Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn Reddit
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

medicaid

The present conversation over Medicaid expansion, as witnessed daily in editorial pages and at the State House, is misleading because the expansion would not do what supporters think it will.

For supporters of Medicaid expansion, the decision is a no-brainer: it’s federal money paying for uninsured poor Mainers to get health care. For them, only politics could motivate the opposition. They whole-heartedly believe an expansion would simply move uninsured people onto Medicaid, thus reducing charity care costs which are ultimately passed along to those covered with private insurance.

But Maine’s own experience expanding medical welfare shows that it does not do what supporters think it does: it doesn’t affect the uninsured population and it doesn’t reduce uncompensated care costs.

Maine submitted a waiver to the federal government in 2002 to expand Medicaid eligibility to childless adults. This first expansion was passed with many of the same goals associated with the current expansion proposal: cover the uninsured and reduce charity care. New Hampshire, at the same time, decided against expansion. Comparing the experiences of the two states provides a highly relevant lesson for today’s policymakers.

Proponents of the first Medicaid expansion said it would reduce Maine’s uninsured population. Yet, in the decade that followed, the number of Mainers without insurance held steady at around 12 percent. Throughout the same timeframe, New Hampshire’s uninsured population remained at 11 percent. Despite one state pursuing expansion and the other opting out, neither saw appreciable change in the number of uninsured residents.

Maine’s uninsured population did not decrease, but the Medicaid rolls certainly swelled. So where did all those new enrollees come from?

In the years following the first Medicaid expansion, the number of people on MaineCare increased 7 percentage points and number of people with private insurance decreased 7 percentage points. Arizona, which also chose to expand their Medicaid program, saw similar results. Arizona’s insured population remained the same, but Medicaid enrollment increased by 5 percentage points and enrollment in private insurance decreased 5 percentage points. The obvious conclusion to be reached is that most new Medicaid enrollees were not previously uninsured. Indeed, the evidence suggests that expanding eligibility in Medicaid simply led many people to cancel private insurance and sign up for free, taxpayer-funded Medicaid.

The other misleading argument for Medicaid expansion is that it will reduce the cost of uncompensated care. In 2004, the first year of the first expansion, charity care cost Maine hospitals $61 million. But by 2011, that number had swelled to $215 million. If expanding Medicaid reduces charity care, then why did charity care increase by 247 percent in the years following an expansion? By comparison, in New Hampshire, hospitals paid $99 million in charity care in 2004. That number grew to $240 million in 2011, a much smaller increase of 142 percent. That Medicaid expansion did little to curb the cost of uncompensated care in Maine should be unsurprising, given the stable level of uninsured individuals who typical utilize charity care.

Providing the uninsured with access to health care and reducing charity care costs are both laudable goals. But the first expansion of Medicaid failed to accomplish either, and so would another. We agree with supporters of Medicaid expansion about the need to insure the uninsured and curb uncompensated care. But expanding eligibility for medical welfare has and will fail to accomplish these goals. Rather than repeat the failed ideas of the past, policymakers should look for new, creative ways to improve Maine’s health care system. Importantly, these reforms should be supported by empirical data, not glib assertions, fanciful forecasts and misleading talking points.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Medicaid Medicaid expansion Opinion
Previous ArticlePortland City Councilor: "If JFK was alive today he'd be a moderate Democrat, like Obama"
Next Article Liberal Democrats eye Fun Tax
Steve Robinson
  • Twitter

Steve Robinson is the Editor-in-Chief of The Maine Wire. ‪He can be reached by email at Robinson@TheMaineWire.com.

Related Posts

Two Men Arrested in Sanford Stabbing and Bike Theft Case

September 29, 2023

South Portland High School Locked Down This Morning After Suspicious Individual Spotted Near Entrance

September 29, 2023

Sen. Dianne Feinstein, Longest-Serving Female Senator, Dead At 90

September 29, 2023

10 Comments

  1. Les Gibson on November 23, 2013 8:04 AM

    Elected Democrats in Augusta, and their liberal media allies, will never have an honest discussion about mexical welfare. They can’t because they know it won’t work, as past results prove. They are pushing this for one reason only…. to expand their voter base. They will lie and use scare tactics to accomplish this goal. And to push the myth that the feds will pay for it all is a fools errand.

  2. Frank J. Heller on November 23, 2013 11:04 AM

    You forget the other big emotional argument….that it would reduce the E.R. overload and the ‘bad debt’ & ‘charity care’ at hospitals.

    Both continued to rise so much the Muskie Institute commissioned a study which documents that, while complex factors were at work, expanding Medicaid was a factor in increasing ER overload in evenings and on weekends; and in increasing non-payment of co-pays, further increasing debt.

    Please read the study, since it’s one of the few benchmark studies of the consequences of expanding Medicaid and the impact on health care institutions.

  3. Bob Stone on January 15, 2014 6:51 AM

    Sending this link to our local hospital CEO’s and board chairs.

  4. doudoune canada goose pas cher on October 3, 2014 10:02 PM

    Heya, many man called Blumenthal was already removed your current infographic as well as submitted that on his blog! We are clueless when he or she acquired admission not really, thus just simply transferring that coupled. Below is his / her url:

  5. veste moncler homme on October 3, 2014 10:03 PM

    Each this above comment thanks at any rate, I figured it (for other people inside the similar location merely available iphoto in addition to dropbox in addition and drag-and-drop concerning applications very simple).

  6. Moises Hislope on October 5, 2014 2:52 PM

    jooouli

  7. homeimprovementdaily.com on October 5, 2014 6:39 PM

    What’s Taking place i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely
    helpful and it has helped me out loads. I am hoping to contribute & assist
    other users like its helped me. Great job.

  8. fake hermes loafers on October 6, 2014 11:27 AM

    fake hermes loafers fake hermes belt buckle nordstrom hsyqigtagwx

  9. Velva Wozney on October 7, 2014 4:01 AM

    You could definitely see your expertise in the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe. Always go after your heart.

  10. тахта угловая on May 28, 2023 2:03 PM

    Greate pieces. Keep writing such kind of information on your page. Im really impressed by your site.

Leave A Reply

Recent News

Two Men Arrested in Sanford Stabbing and Bike Theft Case

September 29, 2023

South Portland High School Locked Down This Morning After Suspicious Individual Spotted Near Entrance

September 29, 2023

Sen. Dianne Feinstein, Longest-Serving Female Senator, Dead At 90

September 29, 2023

Angus King and West Virginia Senator Partner to Designate September as ‘National Recovery Month’ Amid Rise in Overdoses

September 29, 2023

Senate Unanimously Approves Official Business-Appropriate Dress Code

September 29, 2023
Newsletter

News

  • News
  • Campaigns & Elections
  • Opinion & Commentary
  • Media Watch
  • Education
  • Media

Maine Wire

  • About the Maine Wire
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Submit Commentary
  • Complaints
  • Maine Policy Institute

Resources

  • Maine Legislature
  • Legislation Finder
  • Get the Newsletter
  • Maine Wire TV

Facebook Twitter Instagram Steam RSS
  • Post Office Box 7829, Portland, Maine 04112

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Sign In or Register

Welcome Back!

Login below or Register Now.

Lost password?

Register Now!

Already registered? Login.

A password will be e-mailed to you.