Author: Libby Palanza

Libby Palanza is a reporter for the Maine Wire and a lifelong Mainer. She graduated from Harvard University with a degree in Government and History. She can be reached at palanza@themainewire.com.

On Wednesday, President Joe Biden issued a notice of appeal for the injunction issued Tuesday barring federal officials from collaborating with social media companies to remove or suppress “protected free speech.” Issued by Louisiana Judge Terry A. Doughty, the injunction that President Biden is appealing prohibits a number of named federal agencies from working with social media companies to take down, or limit the circulation of, “protected free speech” on their respective platforms. They were also blocked from flagging specific content for deletion or requesting that companies “Be On The Lookout” for certain kinds of “protected free speech.” In the…

Read More

A federal judge issued an injunction Tuesday that blocks members of the Biden Administration and several federal agencies from working with social media companies to exert any form of control over users’ “protected free speech.” Louisiana Judge Terry A. Doughty’s injunction bars the named agencies, including intelligence agencies, from meeting with social media companies concerning the removal of content or urging companies to alter their guidelines for doing so. The injunction also bars federal officials from “specifically flagging content or posts” for “removal, deletion[, or] suppression.” In addition to this, they are blocked from “requesting content reports” from social media…

Read More

The Supreme Court ruled Friday, in a 6-3 decision, that a Colorado state law compelling a website designer to “create expressive designs speaking messages with which the designer disagrees” stands in violation of the First Amendment. In this case, 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, the owner and founder of the graphic design firm 303 Creative LLC, Lorie Smith of Colorado, wanted to expand her business to include the creation of wedding websites. Given that Smith is opposed to same-sex marriage on religious grounds, however, she did not want to design sites for same-sex weddings. As it stands, Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act…

Read More

Following the Supreme Court’s ruling yesterday declaring the use of race-based affirmative action in college admissions unconstitutional, two of Maine’s higher education institutions have entered the conversation. [RELATED: Supreme Court Declares Race-Conscious College Admissions Unconstitutional in Harvard Case] In a statement issued by Bowdoin College, outgoing President Clayton Rose expressed that “it is clear and deeply disappointing that the court overturned more than forty years of precedent that has enhanced diversity in campus communities.” Rose also argued that the Supreme Court’s “decision undermines the essential work to create an educational environment and experience that prepares students for the diverse worlds…

Read More

The Supreme Court issued an opinion this morning officially declaring affirmative action unconstitutional. The case, Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, posed the question of whether higher education institutions could consider an applicant’s race during the admissions process. In their decision, the Court ruled that Harvard College’s race-conscious admissions process actively violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. “Eliminating racial discrimination means eliminating all of it,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in the majority opinion. The Supreme Court first considered race-based admissions policies in the case of Regents of the University of…

Read More

At 3:45 in the morning on Wednesday, the Appropriations Committee voted nearly unanimously to approve a spending package totaling approximately $800 million. Only one member of the Committee, Rep. Jack Ducharme (R-Madison), voted in opposition to the budget. “We pushed hard for a lot of things that we felt very strongly about, and I’m grateful that we have come together,” Sen. Rick Bennett (R-Oxford) of the Appropriations Committee said. Rep. Melanie Sachs (D-Freeport), chair of the Appropriations Committee, also spoke about the budget. “I want to note the amazing, wonderful investment..in the Maine people that this is going to engender,”…

Read More

The Maine Legislature is set to continue debate over LD 168, a bill that would require a “federally licensed firearms dealer” to facilitate “the sale, transfer or exchange” of a firearm unless the buyer and seller are family members. Originally, the bill would have also allowed buyers and sellers to alternatively satisfy this requirement by obtaining a criminal background check from a “law enforcement agency,” but a House amendment struck this provision from the legislation. The House narrowly approved the bill as amended by a roll call vote of 70-65. No Republicans voted for the bill. Six Democrats joined the…

Read More

Mainers must be 21-years-old to buy tobacco products and at least 18-years-old to use a tanning salon. But if Gov. Janet Mills allows a bill approved this week by Maine lawmakers to become law, then minors as young as 16 will be allowed to get puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones — even in cases where their parents object to the medical intervention. The 73-60 roll call vote in the House fell nearly along party lines. Rep. Sawin Millett (R-Waterford) joined the Democrats in support of the bill, and Rep. Kevin O’Connell (D-Brewer) and Rep. Traci Gere (D-Kennebunkport) joined the Republicans…

Read More

Democratic lawmakers voted Friday to kill a bill that would have prohibited public school employees from addressing students by alternative names or pronouns without written consent from a parent or legal guardian. The bill, LD 678, was defeated first in House and then by a party-line roll call vote of 20-12 in the Senate. The bill originally would have required teachers and other employees to use only the name and pronouns listed on a student’s birth certificate unless written permission was provided. Amended versions of the bill, however, would have required those working in public schools to use the name,…

Read More

The Legislature passed a resolution Friday directing the Governor’s Office to establish a working group tasked with studying the ability of “safe consumption sites” to effectively prevent opioid overdose deaths. “Safe consumption sites” are facilities where individuals can use previously-obtained illicit drugs under medical supervision without fear of arrest. Originally, the Legislature was considering a bill that would have authorized towns and cities to establish “safe consumption sites” if they desired to do so. Proponents of the bill suggested that such sites are essential to addressing the epidemic of drug overdose deaths. Opponents, on the other hand, argued that there…

Read More

Party-line votes in both the House and Senate earlier this week killed a bill that would have required Maine voters to present a photo ID when casting their ballots, whether that be in person or absentee, starting on January 1, 2024. The bill, LD 1365, listed a number of eligible types of photo identification, including a drivers license, state ID, United States passport, military ID, or permit to carry a concealed handgun. Free voter identification cards would have been made available to those who wished to vote but did not have access to one of the other eligible forms of…

Read More

The Legislature voted unanimously this week to ban TikTok from all electronic devices owned or controlled by the state government. Following the initial introduction of LD 1007, a directive was issued by Maine Information Technology (MaineIT) stating that any applications developed by ByteDance Limited, including TikTok, are prohibited from all state-issued devices, as well as any personal devices connected to state systems. MaineIT also this week delivered a memorandum to all state employees instructed them that use of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies were prohibited. Rep. Nathan M. Carlow (R-Buxton), the bill’s sponsor, testified before the Committee on State and…

Read More

Over the past few days, the Legislature has shot down a series of bills and resolutions aimed at shoring up parental rights, safeguarding against the politicization of education, and expanding opportunities for school choice. LD 1953: Resolution, Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of Maine to Establish a Parental Bill of Rights LD 1953, proposed by Rep. Jennifer L. Poirier (R-Skowhegan), would have given Maine voters the opportunity to weigh in a potential amendment to the State Constitution establishing parental rights. The proposed amendment would have read: “The natural, inherent and unalienable rights of minor children are held by their…

Read More

The State Legislature has officially defeated a bill that would have lowered Maine’s sales tax rate from 5.5 percent to 5.25 percent on October 1, 2023, and to 5 percent on July 1, 2024. The bill, LD 1747, would not have impacted the sales tax rates for “prepared food, lodging, rental vehicles, liquor or adult use cannabis.” In 2013, Maine “temporarily” enacted a sales tax increase, raising the rate from 5% to 5.5%, for the period of October 1, 2013 through June 30, 2015, but this change was extended indefinitely in 2015. Assistant House Minority Leader Amy Arata (R-New Gloucester),…

Read More

The Senate voted Tuesday to require MaineCare reimbursement for “medically necessary treatment for or related to gender dysphoria,” following a similar vote from the House earlier in the week. Senate Democrats rejected on party lines an amendment that would have ensured coverage for complications related to, or the reversal of, such so-called “gender-affirming care.” House Democrats had killed a similar amendment earlier in the week. The amendment, introduced by Rep. Katrina Smith (R-Palermo) in the House and Sen. Stacey Guerin (R-Penobscot) in the Senate, would have guaranteed that those who received gender-affirming care would have access to health care for…

Read More

Lawmakers voted Wednesday to kill a bill that would have facilitated the installation of “safe haven baby boxes,” referred to in the legislation as “newborn safety devices,” in hospitals, law enforcement agencies, and fire departments throughout Maine. To date, inaction on the part of the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) has prevented these facilities from getting safe haven baby boxes installed on their premises. A safe haven baby box “legally permits a mother in crisis to safely, securely, and anonymously surrender if they are unable to care for their newborn.” Last year, the Legislature approved a bill, LD…

Read More

The Senate resoundingly rejected last week a bill that would have raised vehicle inspection costs and given the Maine State Police (MSP) the authority to create an electronic surveillance system to track vehicle inspections. Following the House’s approval of the measure, the Senate defeated the legislation Friday in a 30-2 roll call vote. Sen. Brad Farrin (R-Somerset) and Sen. Matthew Pouliot (R-Kennebec) were the only two legislators in the Senate who expressed support for the measure. Under the original draft of the bill, introduced by Rep. Bruce White (D-Waterville), participation in the program would be voluntary for mechanics, but it…

Read More

Late last week, the Senate defeated a bill that would have abolished Maine’s state income tax and established a zero-based budgeting system. The result was a foregone conclusion considering the Democratic-controlled Legislature dismissed the thought of tax reductions earlier this year during debates over the Gov. Janet Mills’ partisan budget. Had the bill been passed, Maine’s income tax would have been eliminated starting January 1, 2026. The bill, LD 1434, also would have established a zero-based budgeting system in time for fiscal year 2025-26. In the context of this bill, a zero-based budget refers to a system “in which programs…

Read More

The Senate voted Tuesday along party lines to reject a bill that would have restricted the use of private donations to fund election administration in Maine. LD 1869, introduced by Sen. Trey Stewart (R-Aroostook), would have required that municipalities submit a report to the Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices within 30 days of “spending funds received from a private source in excess of $100 on the administration of an election.” Such a report would need to include “the amount of the funds received by the municipality, the source of the funds and a detailed explanation of how the…

Read More

A federal court of appeals released an opinion Friday siding with the Maine Lobstermen’s Association in their lawsuit against the National Marine Fisheries Service, a subagency of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). In September of 2021, the Maine Lobstermen’s Association filed a lawsuit against the regulator alleging that their efforts to protect the North Atlantic right whale were unlawful. The North Atlantic right whale has been on the endangered species list ever since the classification was established, and according to a recent report, cited in Friday’s decision, there are only about 368 still alive today. The lawsuit filed…

Read More

Municipalities across the state were granted a reprieve last week when LD 1706 was signed into law, extending the deadline for towns and cities to bring their local housing ordinances into compliance with LD 2003, the affordable housing legislation passed last year. Originally, municipalities only had until July 1, 2023 to figure out how to incorporate the bill’s mandates into their existing local ordinances. In light of LD 1706, however, “municipalities for which ordinances may be enacted by the municipal officers without further action or approval by the voters of the municipality” have until January 1, 2024 to make the…

Read More

The state of Maine has lurched from short-term spending agreement to short-term spending agreement, often using pricey borrowing to pay for Maine’s roads and bridges for years. But Republican lawmakers said Friday they’ve finally won support for a GOP idea that will dedicate tax revenue to an infrastructure spending fund. Under the terms of the supplemental spending bill Republicans and Democrats agreed to this week, the state will dedicate 40 percent of the sales tax collected on vehicle purchases, as well as 40 percent of the sales and use taxes collected by the Bureau of Motor Vehicles, to the Highway…

Read More

Maine’s school rank 34th among all 50 states in the nation when it comes to education, according the 2023 Kids Count Data Book published by the Annie E. Casey Foundation. Maine’s Department of Health and Human Service Commissioner Jeanne Lambrew touted the report this week in an email to DHHS employees, noting that Maine ranked 12th in an overall measure that included child poverty, health care, and family health. The Annie E. Casey Foundation is a philanthropic organization based in Baltimore that focuses on “developing a brighter future for millions of children and young people with respect to their educational,…

Read More

The State Legislature has rejected a bill that would have expanded school choice in Maine by creating an Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program. The vote fell strictly along partisan lines in the Senate, and nearly along partisan lines in the House. The only Republican to vote against the bill was Rep. Abden Simmons (R-Waldoboro), who just flipped District 45’s seat from blue to red in a special election held last Tuesday. After publication of this story, Rep. Simmons stated that his vote was cast in error. Although he initially attempted to have his vote changed, he ultimately decided not to…

Read More

Democratic House lawmakers on Thursday killed a bill that would have guaranteed parents’ “fundamental right to make decisions regarding the upbringing, education and well-being” of their children. The parental rights bill, LD 1800, died after the House voted to kill it Thursday, with all present Republicans voting in support and all Democrats against. The Senate had earlier voted against the bill, also along strictly partisan lines. Under this bill, parents would have been given the right “to access all information regarding the school activities,” including “all teaching or instructional materials, required textbooks, course syllabi, lesson plans and other teaching aids…

Read More

St. Dominic Academy in Auburn filed a lawsuit Tuesday against the Mills Administration and the Maine Human Rights Commission alleging that state has engaged in religious discrimination against the Catholic school. The lawsuit names Maine Department of Education Commissioner Pender Makin as well as Maine Human Rights Commissioners Jefferson Ashby, Edward David, Ann O’Brien, Mark Walker, and Thomas Douglas, and alleges multiple human rights violations. [RELATED: Maine Education Chief: “Academic Learning” Takes Backseat to Social-Emotional, Gender, and Race…] Joining St. Dominic Academy, which is run by the Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland, are Maine parents Keith and Valori Radonis. The…

Read More

Whether Maine will hike the statewide hourly minimum wage to $15.00 per hour is in Gov. Janet Mills’ hands after lawmakers voted this week on a proposal that would also establish new annual cost of living adjustments. The bill, LD 1376, passed by only a single vote in the House of Representatives, with a handful of Democratic lawmakers bucking party leadership to oppose the bill. The Senate approved the bill by a larger margin Tuesday. Originally, the bill contained language that, in addition to raising the minimum wage to $15 at the start of next year, would have mandated an…

Read More

Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows (D) is going head-to-head with No Labels, the political third party that has pledged to run a “Unity Ticket” in 2024 should the two major parties “select candidates the vast majority of Americans don’t want to vote for.” Secretary Bellows has challenged the validity of No Labels’ 6,000-plus enrollment in the state, claiming that the group misled voters to believe they were signing a petition to support the party, not changing their party registration. These concerns prompted her to send a cease-and-desist letter to the No Labels Party, as well as individual letters to…

Read More

State lawmakers are considering a proposal to let cities and towns create areas where narcotic users can consume the illegal drugs without fearing arrest. A bill under consideration in the Maine State Legislature, LD 1364, would authorize municipalities to open so-called “safe consumption sites,” also known as safe injection sites. The bill outlines a number of requirements which must be met in order for a safe injection site to be approved, including the provision of “a hygienic location supervised by a health care professional and other trained staff where a client may self-administer previously obtained drugs” and “sterile drug use…

Read More

The South Portland City Council is set to hold a workshop on Thursday to discuss implementing a citywide “Pay As You Throw” (PAYT) program for trash removal, intended to be coupled with a curbside food waste collection program. The meeting’s agenda says the purpose of the upcoming workshop is to “provide information to Councilors and the public about the rationale for a PAYT program and what options exist.” Sustainability Director Julie Rosenbach and Sustainability Program Manager Susan Parmelee will be present at the workshop to share additional information and answer questions. A memo from Rosenbach and Parmelee, attached to the…

Read More

Over the past few years, corporate leaders have worked to acclimate to a culture wherein there seemed to be an expectation that brands take a stand on every hot-button topic. This, however, may no longer be the case. American executives and business owners are rethinking their embrace of hot-button left-wing causes — or any political causes, according to a report in the Wall Street Journal. Chief Executive of PPG Industries Tim Knavish was quoted by the Wall Street Journal concerning his process for reevaluating the company’s strategy for getting involved in politically charged conversations. “We run a business. We don’t…

Read More

Maine had the third highest percentage of out-of-state campaign contributions during the 2022 election cycle at 67.82 percent, according to a recent report from the campaign finance transparency group OpenSecrets. OpenSecrets is a non-profit organization that specializes in the tracking and analysis of campaign finance data. Out-of-state campaign contributions to federal races have become increasingly common nationwide over the last two decades, due in large part to the ever increasing cost of running for federal office. OpenSecrets reported that in 2000, the average winner of U.S. Senate races spent $7.3 million. Today, the same campaign costs $26.5 million, more than…

Read More

State lawmakers are considering a bill that would increase the cost of vehicle inspection fees and create a new surveillance program that would require auto mechanics to submit information about inspections to the Maine State Police. Rep. Bruce White (D-Waterville) originally proposed the bill, LD 900, to streamline and modernize the vehicle inspections process. But it would also give the Maine State Police the power to create an electronic surveillance system that would track vehicle inspections. The original bill provided that participation would be voluntary for auto mechanics; however, an amendment filed over the weekend would allow the Maine State…

Read More

The Maine State Legislature voted this week to kill LD 1636, “An Act to Ensure the Right to Work Without Payment of Dues or Fees to a Labor Union.” The bill, sponsored by Sen. Eric Brakey (R-Androscoggin), would have prohibited both public and private sector employees from being required to either join a union or pay union dues as a condition of their employment. In testimony before the Joint Standing Committee on Labor and Housing, Sen. Brakey explained that the bill was designed to protect the “unalienable” right to work for “those who are compelled to pay dues or fees…

Read More

Able-bodied adults without children will not be required to work or seek employment for a few more years following a party line vote in the Maine House of Representatives to kill LD 784, “An Act to Establish Welfare Work Requirements for Able-bodied Adults Without Dependents.” Sen. Eric Brakey (R-Androscoggin), the sponsor of the bill, said in his testimony before the Committee on Health and Human Services that work requirements align with the goal of the program. It was one of several bills Brakey proposed this session to reform Maine’s various welfare programs. “For those who are able-bodied and capable of…

Read More

Officials within the Biden Administration are preparing for the possibility that the Supreme Court will strike down its large-scale student loan forgiveness program, according to reporting from the Wall Street Journal. It is expected that the Supreme Court will soon issue a decision regarding the Biden Administration’s plan to eliminate an estimated $430 billion in student loans. Should the Court ultimately kill this program, sources told the Wall Street Journal that the administration is likely going to pursue more targeted policy options aimed at helping those who will soon be required to resume student loan payments following the expiration of…

Read More

The Maine State Legislature is expected to soon put its seal of approval on LD 1101, “An Act to Support Lower Home Energy Costs by Establishing a Home Energy Scoring System.” If signed into law, the bill would require the Efficiency Maine Trust to establish a “home energy scoring system” by June 30, 2024 that would evaluate the energy efficiency of residential buildings. Think social credit score but for how well a residential building is living up to the greenhouse gas emissions goals set by politicians in Augusta. The Efficiency Maine Trust will have the freedom to decide on the…

Read More

Democrats in the State Senate and House of Representatives have officially voted to kill bill that would have required public schools to put curriculum materials and other school records online for parents to see. L.D. 1199, “An Act to Provide Transparency in Public School Curricula,” was sponsored by Rep. Rachel A. Henderson (R-Rumford). The bill would have required school boards to make publicly available online by October 1 of each school year “curriculum and library-related materials,” including teaching materials, a list of required textbooks, syllabi, lesson plans, tests, and “a list of books available in the library and the intended…

Read More

Officials at Gardiner Area High School have implemented a temporary policy banning the display of all flags on school grounds — aside from the American flag — following a recent clash between students putting up LGBTQ+ flags and those hanging Trump flags, according to reporting from WGME. From WGME: School officials say the incident that sparked the ban was when students put up and removed flags inside the school with competing political and social messages. School leaders say the incident led to students picking sides and even what the superintendent described as a heated altercation. Some are upset about how…

Read More

Democrats are poised to kill a resolution from Rep. Katrina J. Smith (R-Palermo) that would have instructed the Maine Department of Education to adopt rules that block public school teachers from engaging in political, ideological, or religious indoctrination. “This resolve protects every viewpoint, because it keeps every personal opinion out of the classroom,” Rep. Smith said in her testimony before the Committee on Education and Cultural Affairs. Smith’s resolution would have instructed the State Board of Education to adopt clear rules and enforcement mechanisms to ensure “appropriate and professional ethical behavior by teachers” by prohibiting them “from using the classroom…

Read More